Free State left UK at just the right moment

Garrett FitzGerald argues that some revisionists have taken the re-drafting of history too far. In particular, he argues that the southern state got out of the UK before it was economically too late (subs needed) to kick out for economic independence, “at a moment when the cost of the break was still bearable, involving as it did only a small reduction in public service salaries and in the very limited social welfare provisions of that period”. It is true that …

Read more…

Double-bluff?.. or a lack of foresight?

The Irish Times’ Frank Millar has a closer look at the joint statement from Taoiseach Bertie Ahern and Prime Minister Tony Blair, and the subsequent clarification from Secretary of State for Wales and Northern Ireland Peter Hain. Frank Millar’s interpretation seems to echo that of the Belfast Telegraph’s Brian Walker [although the emphasis is different] and he highlights that with the mixed messages coming from the governments on how they envisage moving beyond that November 24th deadline, “After all the …

Read more…

DUP to end ‘cold war’ with inter governmental forum?

Some would argue that the DUP’s prolonged boycott of the British and Irish Interparliamentary Body was mostly a case of never having quite getting round to attending rather than a key issue of principle. After all, its function is essentially East West rather than North South. Nevertheless, their decision to send observers is being seen as a positive move towards some form of rapprochement. Mick FealtyMick is founding editor of Slugger. He has written papers on the impacts of the …

Read more…

Lots of talk and consequences for everyone but Sinn Fein

According to Alex Kane, the message coming from the two governments last week it is time for the two main parties to deal with each other. But he notes the financial penalties arising from any future collapse are likely to affect everyone, except “IRA-bankrolled Sinn Fein”. Indeed, last night’s documentary on Trimble pretty much repeated the view that the IRA’s ‘no show’ act of decommissioning in October 2003, occurred because there was no political pressure on them to produce anything.He …

Read more…

Italy on a knife edge…

Henry Farrell has a few useful first thoughts on the outcome of yesterday’s election result, which leaves Prodi on a one seat majority in the Italian Senate, and a potentially unwieldy coalition comprising two communist parties and a smattering of economic liberals. Mick FealtyMick is founding editor of Slugger. He has written papers on the impacts of the Internet on politics and the wider media and is a regular guest and speaking events across Ireland, the UK and Europe. Twitter: …

Read more…

DUP to meet with British-Irish Interparliamentary Body

RTÉ may have jumped to conclusions with this report, but it is a move that seems to have taken the UUP by surprise. The BBC clarifies the situation somewhat. While the DUP MP Jeffrey Donaldson, speaking on Talkback, described the move as responding to an invitation from Paul Murphy to make a presentation to the British-Irish Interparliamentary Body in Killarney, County Kerry on 24 April. Pete Baker

“a great opportunity”

It would be remiss not to note that 8 years ago today some, by now, very familiar statements were being made.. although not necessarily by the same people.. Pete Baker

New peers to be announced tomorrow

Well it’s been predicted for some time, Slugger noted an IT report in August last year, but the latest reports are that it will be announced officially tomorrow – Lady Paisley, Lord Browne, Lord Morrow.. and, of course, Lord Trimble. Update That’s Baroness Paisley of St George’s.. apparently.. Pete Baker

On the necessary moral force of the state

Interesting to see that the great journalistic splash around the Donaldson case has brought Oliver Kamm into the Northern Ireland space, if only to illustrate an argument on morality of state force. He begins by noting Dean Godson’s remarks in the Daily Telegraph that “Mr Blair has become the prisoner of the peace process. Like a gambler who has invested so much, he has to keep heaping on the chips to obtain a return”.Kamm sets of with key statement 1: …

Read more…

Say hello to the new Presiding Officer..

The BBC are reporting that the Assembly next speaker is about to be appointed by the NIO, since Lord Alderdice is otherwise engaged, and in what seems to be somewhat of a party-political trend, that speaker is to be former Alliance Party deputy leader Eileen Bell who has already announced that she will not stand in the next [If there is one – Ed] assembly elections. Pete Baker

remarkable for its vagueness and lack of detail

In the Belfast Telegraph, Brian Walker is less than impressed with the lack of detail in yesterday’s joint statement from Taoiseach Bertie Ahern and Prime Minister Tony Blair, arguing that “the ‘stick’ of green-tinged direct rule would seem to hold few terrors for the DUP and the ‘carrot’ of committees by itself is far too unappetising to tempt anybody else”. It’s difficult to detect anything, threat [or] promise, in the PMs’ framework that creates a dynamic for breaking the deadlock. …

Read more…

“an opportunity for all”

RTÉ very briefly notes it, but the PA report has more detail. The joint statement from the governments yesterday was welcomed by the US President, naturally enough, and, as well as calling on all parties to demonstrate leadership, the statement from the Whitehouse makes particular mention of policing and “an unequivocal commitment to the rule of law and the renunciation of all paramilitary and criminal activities.” Update To note, that particular line is not included in the BBC report. Other …

Read more…

If by 24 November the Assembly has failed..

As well as the big stick waving in the media, the two premiers have released a joint statement to accompany the announcement in Armagh today. Assembly to sit for 6 weeks from 15 May, then for a further 12 weeks after a summer recess. [So they did blink then? – Ed]Full statement below – Joint Statement by the Prime Minister and the Taoiseach – Armagh, 6 April 2006 1.In recent months we have held discussions with all the political parties …

Read more…

“this time really is different”

Secretary of State for Wales and Northern Ireland, Peter Hain, is waving his big stick, again, in the Guardian today, ending with the familiar, by now, line – “If locally elected politicians don’t like all this, the solution lies in their hands: taking their places at Stormont and, for the first time in over three years, earning their salaries by exercising self-government.” [Also available on the Guardian’s Commentisfree blog – Ed] Some will say with misplaced confidence that we have …

Read more…

Moving on.. again?

Despite the apparent narrative, the likelihood is that having already sidestepped one deadline for revealing their blueprint, the Irish and British governments were not going to delay their much vaunted visit to Armagh tomorrow in response to the murder of an informer, however brutal and violent that murder was. Instead, as Mick suggested in a post on one conspiracy theorist, the competing narratives are left to battle for supremacy… not for the first time where Denis Donaldson is concerned.. and …

Read more…

McFarlane trial date set for October

On the same day that Leonard Hardy was sentenced in Germany, and after a lengthy legal tussle over whether or not he would face trial, the date for the trial of the prominent Provisional IRA member Brendan McFarlane, for the kidnapping of businessman Don Tidey in 1983, was set by the Special Criminal Court for 3rd October this year. His defence team told the court that McFarlane intends to make a new application for a judicial review of the case, …

Read more…

Westminster on the Assets Recovery Agency

The Northern Ireland Affairs Committee is working on Organised Crime in Northern Ireland. Some of the sections of uncorrected evidence make for fascinating reading, even if it takes them a while to get it up on the site. Here’s a few snippets from concerning the Assets Recovery Agency‘s proposal that its powers be beefed up to make it comparable to the Criminal Assets Bureau in the Republic, and a question from Alisdair McDonnell on why most of the asset recovered …

Read more…

New moves on Civil Partnership in Republic?

Staying with the Republic, the Irish Times has an extraordinary picture of the Taoiseach sticking his tongue out at the launch the Gay and Lesbian Equality Network’s programme for equality for gay, lesbian and bisexual people in Dublin yesterday. As Miriam Lord notes in her column in the Independent, it was another masterly stroke from a leader with an unerring instinct for timing: …it’s difficult, particularly in this day and age, to believe that, yesterday, Bertie Ahern became the first …

Read more…

NIO strategy [for loyalists] unravelling?

The BBC reports that “Presbyterian minister Reverend Mervyn Gibson has been ousted as chairman of the Loyalist Commission”, and suggests a link to a NIO initiative “which would include the loyal orders and nationalist residents groups” – [Nothing to do with this strategy then? -Ed]. But the last public mention of Mervyn Gibson, now formerly chairman of the Loyalist Commission, was when the DUP acknowledged holding meetings with him, meetings that they had decided to continue. Pete Baker

Voters don’t care what you think or say?

Here’s a snippet to conjure with. It comes through the ESRC’s Society Today website. Dr James Tilley describes a test conducted during the last European election in which respondents were tested for their responses to certain objective data: “Contrary to what one might expect, we found that only a minority of respondents changed their views on parties’ policies on European integration,” Dr Tilley explains. “And those most likely to change tended to be the least sophisticated.” Hmmm… Before we get …

Read more…