Ireland to beat South Africa?

There were some interesting riffs in last week-end’s matches on my theme from my last post – that rugby is still a sport where the team which needs/wants it most can sometimes overcome a superior but slightly less motivated team.

Pride of place has to go to Wales’ first win against the All Blacks in 73 years – a period which encompasses the halcyon days of Gareth Edwards, Barry John, Phil Bennett, Gerald Dawes, Jonathan Davies, JPR Williams, Gethin Jenkins, Mervyn Davies, Sam Warburton, and Alun Wyn Jones – none of whom achieved that honour in a Welsh jersey.

France were also highly motivated to make amends for their narrow home World Cup defeat to South Africa – and duly achieved a narrow and somewhat fortuitous victory in a fiercely physical contest. Fortune often favours the brave – and so can match officials.

Much has been made of Rassie Erasmus’ rant against the official in this match, but Ireland also had much to complain about in their scrappy win against Fiji. Ireland had what seemed to me no less than three legitimate tries ruleds out by referee Angus Gardner and his TMO -my old bête noire Mike Adamson – whom I have never seen having a good game as a referee.

Firstly, Gibson Park was clearly tackled around the neck as he attempted to ground the ball over the try line – why was a penalty try not awarded? Then Nick Timoney could be seen grounding the ball by all except the TMO. And finally, debutant James McNabney was diving for the line when he was smashed in the face and knocked out cold by a swinging arm by Ravuivasa who also landed on top of him. How both the TMO and the citing officer could deem that this did not meet the threshold for a red card – while a typical Prendergast non tackle did – is beyond me.

However, true to form, Ireland did not make public complaints or excuses and got on with the game. Perhaps Rassie Erasmus should take note. If there are valid complaints there are proper channels for making them and I hope World Rugby have been made fully aware of a pattern of poor officiating against Irish teams by Mike Adamson, in particular.

Which brings me to the question of which team will have the greater motivation to win next Saturday. Last week I argued that Andy Farrell should make fifteen changes to his starting team for the Fiji match on the grounds that all would have a lot to play for – unlike the first team who were coming off a good performance in a very physical match against Argentina.

In the event, Farrell made only seven changes to his team, and the result was a fitful display which lacked intensity until Ireland pulled away in the second half. Hardly any player embellished their reputation, and we were fortunate that only two players – neither first choice – came off with injuries. If we are ever going to win a World Cup, we have got to learn to trust our back-up players more.

All that said, we should be fully locked and loaded for the game against South Africa, even if we are missing Garry Ringrose at 13 and no less than our top five no.8’s – Caelan Doris, Jack Conan, Seán Jansen, Bryn Ward, and the aforementioned James McNabney.

Last year we were missing our top three looseheads and got hammered in the scrums. Let’s hope that the experiment of playing hooker and skipper Dan Sheehan at no. 8 pays off. However one can only wonder what message his selection there sends to other experienced back-rowers in the squad like Nick Timoney and Cian Prendergast. Timoney was one of the few who had a good game against Fiji, and still does not make the team as the starting 8.

My suspicion is that Farrell regards Kelleher as our top scrummaging hooker – a priority against South Africa – but that Dan Sheehan is undropable because of the quality of his all round game. The proof of the pudding will be in the eating – if Ireland can match South Africa in the tight and our back row can match them in the loose, we will be in with a shout.

South Africa have a very good set of backs, but they are used to being given an armchair ride by their very dominant forward pack and it will be interesting to see how they perform if Ireland can achieve anything close to parity up front. Ireland could play very well and still lose, and could be routed if they play even 5% off their best game.

If ever there were a time to put your best foot forward, this would be it. Ireland have everything to play for, and the example of Wales and France to follow. They were undercooked at the same stage last year but have now survived two physical contests in a row. Lets hope they are fully recovered from their exertions and ready for another season defining performance.

One aspect of Erasmus’ tactics which has received surprising little comment is his practice of naming his team early, and then switching his front rows an hour prior to the match – in clear breach of World rugby regulations – which allow for late changes only in exceptional circumstances like injury immediately prior to the match – in which case an “injured” player would not be able to take his place on the bench either.

I would have thought a referee would be within his rights to insist that the team as named take the field and refuse to allow any player not originally named to take the field. I suppose the SA coaching ticket (minus Rassie) could comply by taking the field as originally announced and then substituting the starting front row at the first stoppage. However, a substituted player can only retake the field with the referee’s permission and the referee could refuse permission if he felt the original substitution was purely tactical and “the spirit of the game” was being abused.

We praise coaches when they innovate, but perhaps referees should also be more innovative as in ensuring the rules are applied as intended. Discuss!

IRELAND: Hugo Keenan; Robert Baloucoune, Robbie Henshaw, Stuart McCloskey, Mack Hansen; Sam Prendergast, Jamison Gibson-Park; Andrew Porter, Rónan Kelleher, Tadhg Furlong; Joe McCarthy, Tadhg Beirne; Ryan Baird, Josh van der Flier, Dan Sheehan (capt).

Replacements 5:3: Tom Stewart, Tom O’Toole, Sam Illo, James Ryan, Nick Timoney, Craig Casey, Ciarán Frawley, Bundee Aki.

SOUTH AFRICA (as originally announced): Damian Willemse; Kurt-Lee Arendse, Jesse Kriel, Damian de Allende, Ethan Hooker; Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, Morne van den Berg; Ox Nche, Malcolm Marx, Wilco Louw; Eben Etzebeth, Ruan Nortje; Siya Kolisi (capt), Pieter-Steph du Toit, Cameron Hanekom.

Replacements 6:2: Jan-Hendrik Wessels, Gerhard Steenekamp, Thomas du Toit, Lood de Jager, Paul de Villiers, Marco van Staden, Grant Williams, Canan Moodie.

 

 

 


Discover more from Slugger O'Toole

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

We are reader supported. Donate to keep Slugger lit!

For over 20 years, Slugger has been an independent place for debate and new ideas. We have published over 40,000 posts and over one and a half million comments on the site. Each month we have over 70,000 readers. All this we have accomplished with only volunteers we have never had any paid staff.

Slugger does not receive any funding, and we respect our readers, so we will never run intrusive ads or sponsored posts. Instead, we are reader-supported. Help us keep Slugger independent by becoming a friend of Slugger. While we run a tight ship and no one gets paid to write, we need money to help us cover our costs.

If you like what we do, we are asking you to consider giving a monthly donation of any amount, or you can give a one-off donation. Any amount is appreciated.