If you can’t wait for an Assembly crisis to peak over the glacially slow process of deciding if Michelle O’ Neill is going to be prosecuted over blocking Garvaghy Road, look no further than the Budget deadlock. In this case all the parties seem to be united against the UK government. None has broken ranks so far. Secretary of State Chris Bryant is said to be on the brink of imposing a budget on Northern Ireland as the Executive refuse yet again to set one for themselves. And their reason? Westminster’s settlement is too low, less than the going rates for Scotland and Wales. There is a message from HM Treasury here.
Is this bluff? If so who’s bluffing?. Going by the history of rattling the begging bowl beyond the last minute, you’d have to guess Bryant. He’s already increased the offer of extra funding from an initial No, nothing to reach £ 1.5 billion in two stages. One more heave? Finance Minister John O’Dowd insists on £1.6 billion – not much you’d think. But wait a sec. The £1.5 billion is spread over three years so the gap is a yawning one, even though according to the Pivotal think tank the over spend is closer to £1 billion or even less. Then again these are titchy sums in comparison to the basic block grant of £ 18 billion, 124% of the English level per head. So is £1.5 bn worth r going into austerity for?
The problem is that the overspend has become cyclical. This series of top ups began after the Assembly resumed in 2024 and has been allowed to accumulate ever since. The UK government gave fair warning of a cliff edge this year and now the Executive is about to fall over it. Without a budget they can only spend less than 95 % of last year in cash terms, reaching another crisis by February. Bryant is insisting they raise revenue of £200m which would mean doubling the rates. Half way into the year that’s impossible even if they agreed. So is a solution beyond an ever ballooning shortfall impossible?
The problem is, while the long neglected outcomes are infinitely desirable – shorter hospital waiting times, clean water, new infrastructure, better secondary education, and so on – but the means of a achieving them are unpalatable. Sinn Fein would not even allow bus fares to rise by the rate of inflation. Jon Burrows the new unionist leader announced he would oppose the withdrawal of general surgery from Coleraine hospital in his constituency, as planned by his predecessor Health minister Mike Nesbitt. Nesbitt quit . And Burrows is being touted as one of the more reasonable ones.
For a solution the facts have to change. The head of the watchdog Fiscal Council points to part of the way. ( Robert Chote has served as head of the UK’s powerful Office for Budget Responsibility)
Reduce civil service numbers and end pay parity with England. It locks in 60 % of the cash spends NI’s civil service numbers are 44% higher per head than England’s. But end pay parity and stand by for health service strikes. Charge water rates. Sinn Fein has set their faces against them. The only solution seems between the imposition of an austerity budget and new taxes. Is that even legal? Doubtful without the suspension of the Assembly and the end of the UK ‘s laissez faire inertia of the post Brexit years, introducing a whole new era of constitutional friction. Or a radical change of heart by the Assembly at the least favourable time in the runup to go the elections in May The only other choice is to do an Andy Burnham convene a debate on the exercise of power by the Assembly and hope to implement constructive results next year, well after the election.
Where would the ideas for change come from? No sign of them from within. For the scale of the challenge, Assembly reforms recently proposed by the opposition SDLP fail to rise to it. End the blocking mechanism by three minsters, elect the Speaker by a two third majority to allow a suspended Assembly to reconvene without a single party veto . By all means. And let’s have joint First Ministers too . Nothing radical . The SDLP flirts with examining a voluntary coalition but fail to recommend how to would work. Demography would look after community parity. The point would be for a majority to agree a programme for government quickly and implement it by effective collective responsibility after open debate led by effective first ministers. It’s abundantly clear that the real power does not rest with the title holders .It would be good to discover where it does lie.
In reality Assembly reform faces an implacable veto. The only way I can see to change is is either a stunning change of heart or pressure from outside. And that can only from the two governments. Theoretically the operation of devolution is not a matter for Dublin but that has never held them back in the past, with British acquiescence. Might it start with the imposition of a budget and see what happens?
Former BBC journalist and manager in Belfast, Manchester and London, Editor Spolight; Political Editor BBC NI; Current Affairs Commissioning editor BBC Radio 4; Editor Political and Parliamentary Programmes, BBC Westminster; former London Editor Belfast Telegraph. Hon Senior Research Fellow, The Constitution Unit, Univ Coll. London
Discover more from Slugger O'Toole
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
