Christopher McCracken is the Managing Director of the Linen Quarter BID
Northern Ireland has its mansions, its luxury cars and its share of people who have done well for themselves. Nobody disputes that. But spotting wealth is easy. Turning it into billions of pounds of public revenue is quite another matter.
Sam McBride’s argument (Belfast Telegraph, 7 November) rests on an alluring proposition: that Stormont’s financial problems could be solved if only it had the courage to make the wealthy pay more. It is a seductive line, particularly when set against images of expensive houses and conspicuous consumption. But it is not a credible economic argument.
A successful business is not a bottomless cash machine for the Executive. Nor is a comfortable lifestyle proof of an inexhaustible fortune waiting to be taxed.
Consider rates. Mr McBride suggests that owners of larger properties should face significantly higher tax. Yet many people living in large houses may have a valuable property, but not a particularly large income. Should they be punished for having spent a lifetime paying off their mortgage, perhaps even forced from a home full of family memories? Wealth on paper is not money in the bank.
And what would removing the rates cap actually achieve? Department of Finance figures put the additional revenue at around £11 million in 2023–24, of which only £5.4 million would have gone to the Executive. More recent estimates put the total at around £13 million. Against a departmental budget of £19.3 billion, that is a drop in the ocean. It is hardly the answer to Stormont’s financial problems.
Nor are expensive homes some lightly taxed preserve of the wealthy. A £1 million home in Northern Ireland attracts £43,750 in stamp duty and up to £4,885 in annual rates. For a non-UK resident buying an additional property, the bill rises to £113,750. In Ireland, a €1 million home attracts €10,000 in duty and just €903 in annual rates. The contrast is striking.
But the bigger question is not how much wealth Northern Ireland can extract from those who already have it. It is how much wealth it can persuade people to create in the first place.
Capital is mobile. Entrepreneurs are mobile. Investment is mobile. They do not have to stay where the taxman decides they should. Get the balance wrong and the wealth you hoped to tax can simply leave – taking jobs, investment and future tax revenue with it.
Look at Chris Rokos. In September 2026, Britain’s third-highest taxpayer announced that he was moving his residency to Greece. In 2025 he paid £330 million in British taxes. By abolishing the non-dom allowance, which has successfully attracted entrepreneurs for over 200 years, the UK has now gifted Greece with one of its most successful wealth creators, whose tax revenues funded the equivalent of 7,000 teachers every year.
Scotland offers another warning. The Institute for Fiscal Studies recently examined the impact of higher income tax rates. The theoretical additional revenue was £1.8 billion. Once the effects of changing behaviour and weaker underlying earnings growth were taken into account, the forecast net gain was just under £1 billion. Higher taxes can raise money, of course. But the Government’s tax calculator is not the same thing as money actually arriving in the bank.
I want to be clear – there is nothing wrong with asking those who have more to contribute more. But there is a world of difference between a fair contribution and the assumption that the wealthy can be taxed indefinitely without consequence.
The real question is not whether Northern Ireland has wealthy people. Of course it does. It is whether the taxes available to Stormont could raise anything approaching the sums implied by Mr McBride’s argument – and whether the economic price of raising them might ultimately exceed the return.
You cannot tax your way to prosperity by endlessly dividing up a shrinking pool of wealth. The challenge is to make that pool bigger.
Northern Ireland needs more wealth creators, more investment and more successful businesses – not simply a longer list of people for the taxman to pursue.
This is a guest slot to give a platform for new writers either as a one off, or a prelude to becoming part of the regular Slugger team.
Discover more from Slugger O'Toole
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


