Two eloquent contrasting articles one from Roy Greenslade who wouldn’t mind being called a republican sympthiser opposed to violence, and John Paul McCarthy who reads like an uber-( correction) revisonist. The subject is Olivia O’Leary’s eulogy to Seamus Heaney for extending awareness of the northern nationalist experience to the know- nothing south. Pointless to try to arbitrate or adjudicate between them. Both have their points. Of the poet, we take what we like from him. It is his integrity and generosity of spirit that admits those with a half-open mind to get a glimpse of a different truth.