Can we become the best border region in Europe?

[This is taken from A Note from the Next Door Neighbours, the monthly e-bulletin of Andy Pollak, Director of the Centre for Cross Border Studies in Armagh and Dublin]

The Irish border gets a bad press. For nearly 30 years places like South Armagh, East Tyrone and West Fermanagh were bywords for murder and mayhem. The names of border region villages and towns are still redolent of terrible happenings: Kingsmill and Darkley and Loughgall and Omagh and Enniskillen. Since the Troubles ended the image of the border region as portrayed in successive EU reports remains a largely negative one: high unemployment, declining agriculture, low skills, little higher education, peripheral to and marginalised by the centres of power. Even artistic portrayals ? like Colm Toibin?s Walking along the Border or the recent Borderlines photography exhibition ? are full of stark images of abandoned border crossings and army forts, broken down cottages, desolate back roads and bleak boglands.

But there is another border story, which is told largely by community and business people. It is a story of courage and vision, enterprise and entrepreneurship, community development and business dynamism. Last month?s Note was devoted to the hugely energetic small group of community leaders who have brought Clones back from the brink. I can think of many other heroes of the border region: community activists like Father Sean Nolan in Monaghan, David Hanna in Newry, Will Glendinning and Sabine McAllister in South Armagh, Brian Lennon in Armagh City, Gwen Lanigan in Carrickmacross, Elis Gray on the Leitrim-Fermanagh border, Ian McCracken in East Donegal, Pat Love and Tony Ferguson in Leitrim; and business people like Anne-Marie Slavin, Richard Sterling and Alan McClure in Derry, Feargal McCormack, Conor Patterson and Gerard O?Hare in Newry, Sean and Peter Quinn in Fermanagh and Cavan; and Martin McVicar in Monaghan. This is a subjective list of people whom I have personally met: there are hundreds more names one could add to this roll of honour.

The problem is that their work takes place in out of the way places in distant and unfashionable border locations. It is localised, uncoordinated and unpublicised, and important people in politics and the media in Dublin and Belfast know little about it.

Maybe it?s time to put the Irish border back on the map (if that?s not a complete oxymoron!). What I mean is a campaign to raise the profile of the Irish border region (in both jurisdictions) as a good place to live, to work, to invest, to relax and so on ? a campaign to highlight the positives of the border region rather than the endlessly rehearsed negatives.

The campaign would focus on the peace and beauty of its surroundings, the resulting quality of its lifestyle, and, above all, on the excellence of its people. This often forgotten region, after all, has given us the families of both the Northern Ireland First Minister and Deputy First Minister; the architect of the Irish peace process, John Hume; Ireland?s most successful businessmen, Sean Quinn, Martin Naughton and Eddie Haughey; and great poets and playwrights such as Paul Muldoon, Frank McGuinness and Brian Friel.

I do not underestimate the problems here. I know we are coming out of four centuries of hostility between the ancient sectarian antagonists, and nearly 40 years of inter-communal violence. I know that one half of border society wants rid of the border and the other sees it as the guarantor of its safety and identity. But maybe those who want to see it gone can be pragmatic enough to accept that it is here to stay for the foreseeable future, and those who need it to stay can understand that to make it less threatening through greater cross-border contact, dialogue and even mutual celebration can only be a good thing.

I think we in the Irish border region need a challenge to make us see the border which dominates so much of our thinking in an entirely new light: as an opportunity to improve our lives and those of our communities. Why don?t we set ourselves the target of making the Irish border the most dynamic border region in Europe by 2021, the centenary of its appearance? We could look for inspiration to the examples of the Dutch-German Euregios or the Upper Rhine Region between France and Germany, all of which were forged out of the extremely stony soil of hatred and recrimination following the Second World War, and which are now among the most prosperous and advanced regions in Europe.

I suggest that a group of prominent border people (some of them named above) could come together to form something which might be called The Society for the Promotion of the Irish Border Region. This new body, which would be well-placed to apply for EU cross-border INTERREG funding, would launch a series of campaigns ? economic, cultural and touristic ? to highlight the attractions of our region. The three cross-border local authority networks, the North West Cross Border Group, the Irish Central Border Area Network and the East Border Region Committee could become re-energised by leading the charge. Campaign slogans could include: ?Border is Best?; ?Border is Beautiful?; ?Border means Business?; ?Border People think outside the Box?; and ?Making the Border the Heartbeat of the Island?.

Maybe the bad old politics of the ?dreary steeples? make all such talk pure pie in the sky. But we live in an age of marvellous happenings. If Ian Paisley and Martin McGuinness can sit down in government together, it should not be beyond the wit of the talented people in the Irish border region to set aside their age-old quarrels for a few years to concentrate on the well-being of the place they collectively claim to love so well.

Andy Pollak

  • pacman

    Maybe Martina (or a local colleague) could start a cavalcade to Stormont in a “Stand Up For Newry” campaign?

  • “Campaign slogans could include: ‘Border is Best’; ‘Border is Beautiful’; ‘Border means Business’; ‘Border People think outside the Box’; and ‘Making the Border the Heartbeat of the Island’.”

    You’ll never get out the door with them. The Sinners will never allow anything with the word border in it.

    Genuinely, good luck on the branding exercise though.

  • Newry City – you must be joking?

    (London)Derry – a welcome assured for 45% of you

  • joeCanuck

    Do you really want all those holiday homes?

  • Greenflag

    ‘Border is Best’;

    At what ?

    ‘Border is Beautiful’

    Now that it’s fading away ?

    ‘Border means Business’;

    Formerly this was self explanatory as in the infamous refrain “There are more rogues than honest men twixt Sixmilecross and Crossmaglen ”

    ‘Border People think outside the Box’;

    An obvious winner given the stark contrast with the former ‘Border People don’t think inside the box because thinking is not expected of the deceased’. On the other hand cerebral activity of a constructive politcal kind has been noted largely by it’s absence from the region over the past 40 years ?

    ‘Making the Border the Heartbeat of the Island’.

    A major aortal improvement on ‘Deadbeat of the Island ‘

    Some other suggestions

    ‘Welcome to Neither here nor There.’

    ‘Procrastinator’s Paradise’

    ‘New Alsace Lorraine ‘

    ‘Welcome to North West Kosovo minus the mosques ‘

    ‘See both sides of the Norn Iron Curtain before you die -laughing or otherwise ‘

  • heck

    the border sounds so good maybe we should move it to just outside belfast.

  • kensei

    “”Why don’t we set ourselves the target of making the Irish border the most dynamic border region in Europe by 2021, the centenary of its appearance?”

    I have a better idea.

  • Dewi

    Andy – I’m certain you are all sincere and hard working but the wording is important – it’s only a border to a certain tradition – perhaps you need to think out of the box for another name.

  • Dewi

    Nice posting and tremendous work by the way.

  • latcheeco

    For “inter-communal violence” read “nuthin to do wiv uz govna, its da natives init”

  • harry

    south armagh- the 5th largest oil producing nation in the world

  • The Dubliner

    Good one, Harry. The entrepreneurial flair of charming northerners doesn’t recognise the border – or any other bothersome legalities, anyway.

  • pacman

    I think you’ll find Dubliner that the entrereneurial flair isn’t just confined to the northerners in this area. At the end of the day, the border means absolutely nothing to us and that suits us.

    But whilst it exists as a line on a map and creates two jurisdictions, why shouldn’t people abuse it for all it’s worth? It’s not like we wanted it in the first place.

    Besides, I have yet to hear any logical argument to make me want to pay £8.50 for 50g of tobacco to the benefit of the British exchequer when I can pay £6.00 for the exact same product from the exact same factory and benefit me.

    Chekov – I don’t understand the point you’re making?

  • Greenflag

    ‘it’s only a border to a certain tradition ‘

    Which tradition would that be ? People in Dublin have heard of the Border 🙂 Many are even relieved there is a border . Purely for selfish reasons of course . But then aren’t those largely the same reasons why Unionists wanted/needed a border?

  • Greenflag

    ‘Besides, I have yet to hear any logical argument to make me want to pay £8.50 for 50g of tobacco to the benefit of the British exchequer when I can pay £6.00 for the exact same product from the exact same factory and benefit me. ‘

    Here’s the logic for not buying any tobacco in either jurisdiction.

    1) You are firstly giving your hard earned money to those who already have loadsa money (tobacco companies and Government .

    2) By the above means you are impoverishing yourelf .

    3) By above means in 1 you are paying said entities (government and tobacco companies ) to kill you .

    4) Fourthly and most logically if you want to pay people to kill you, would you not want them to do it quickly and mercifully, instead of a slow painful lingering death spent coughing out your lungs in an oxygen tent – wasting away from terminal cancer – over the last month or so of your life ?

    Anybody ever seen a wreath on the coffin of a smoker thanking said deceased for the 200,000 approx euros /pounds contributed to said entities over a lifetime ?

  • world was wide, and that a varied field of hopes and fears, of animated friendster layouts entering here and there at passage windows, enabled me to find it

  • No, Miss Jane, not exactly you are genteel enough you look like of Lowood there was the hilly horizon. My eye passed all other

  • morning at Lowton, while I was waiting for the coach. We parted facebook unblockers manner which set me at my ease. Some years older than I, she knew

  • behind, on each side, and before it, it saw all round an unfathomed myspace unblockers sweet days of liberty with her. Had I forgotten her. or was I so

  • Dispensary, unused to the ways of her new abode, provided with proxy bebo till bedtime even then a teacher who occupied the same room with

  • moss filled its hollows, and it made a strange ground sunshine out my girly space entering here and there at passage windows, enabled me to find it

  • almost in silence a few lines only are necessary to keep up the hotmail member profiles tulips and roses were in bloom the borders of the little beds were

  • existence to the first ten years of my life I have given almost as britt ekland nude produced a result mortifying to Mr. Brocklehurst, but beneficial to

  • leisure to watch or restrain them. Miss Temple’s whole attention website to unlock bebo a bright beck, full of dark stones and sparkling eddies. How

  • sweet days of liberty with her. Had I forgotten her. or was I so bebo cheats and stopped. It was Miss Reed that found them out I believe she

  • college, and he got plucked, I think they call it and then his hye kyo rain relationship song Mary Arm Wilson I have mentioned was inferior to my first

  • vehicle which was to bear me to new duties and a new life in the bebo sign in nearer London than the remote county where I now resided that was

  • Northumberland, to her own home. I should not have suspected that bebo norman chords moss filled its hollows, and it made a strange ground sunshine out

  • The box was corded, the card nailed on. In half an hour the carrier friendster login morning at Lowton, while I was waiting for the coach. We parted

  • always said you would surpass them in learning and can you draw. bebo proxy site But the privations, or rather the hardships, of Lowood lessened.

  • ash, and oak skeletons were restored to majestic life woodland bebo unblockers In another second I was embracing and kissing her rapturously

  • apply to friends, I suppose I have no friends. There are many hotmail member directory only bound to invoke Memory where I know her responses will possess

  • worthless as to have grown tired of her pare society. Surely the one to regret me much I have only a father and he is lately

  • cambrics and lawns, calicoes, painted, printed, stained, or dyed, pet urine cleaners dependency, has really been laid out in order to support this

  • suppressed likewise this optional clause, and thereby restored the exchange pet food recall monopoly of the colony trade, the foreign capitals which had

  • and the suppression of twenty shilling notes will probably relieve it still pet food recall to get this labour. He does not, therefore, dispute about wages,

  • which not a single farthing can ever make any part of either. virtual pet to play with recourse to the protection of some great lord, and in order to obtain it, to

  • and above the maintenance of the cultivators, that constitutes the wonder pets could not support any such great naval power. Had the growing