The Colonial Roots of Northern Ireland’s Education System…

four brown desks inside room

Northern Ireland’s education system has its roots in a colonial model developed by the British Government during the 19th century. Designed to enforce cultural assimilation and maintain social stratification, this educational system was trialled in Ireland before being exported across the British Empire to colonies such as Canada, the Caribbean, and Australasia. While other parts of the UK and its former colonies have since abandoned anachronistic remnants such as academic selection, Northern Ireland retains this divisive framework—a striking testament to …

Read more…

A Review of the DE’s Latest Policy Document: A Curate’s Egg?

person holding pencil writing on notebook

TransformED NI presents an ambitious vision for educational excellence through enhanced teaching, curriculum reform, and professional development while strategically sidestepping contentious structural issues, such as academic selection, which research identifies as key barriers to genuine educational equity. Strategic Ambition, Structural Silence: Promises and Limitations Addressing the challenges of educational reform in Northern Ireland requires confronting deeply rooted social divisions, systemic inequalities, and political sensitivities. Shaped by community segregation and socio-economic disparities, our education system embodies longstanding barriers that resist resolution. …

Read more…

Beyond McMonagle: Examining Political Appointments in Northern Ireland…

a sign that says we are hiring and apply today

The Cost of Political Appointments The recent conviction of Sinn Féin press officer Michael McMonagle for serious child sex offences has highlighted systemic flaws in Northern Ireland’s approach to political appointments. While McMonagle was briefly employed under First Minister Michelle O’Neill’s staffing allowance, subsequent revelations—including a party colleague providing an employment reference—have raised considerable concerns about vetting and accountability. This case exemplifies broader issues—opaque appointment processes, inadequate oversight, and blurred lines between party and public interests—that persist across Stormont and …

Read more…

From 17th-Century Ecclesiastical Scholarship to Modern-Day Science Education: Less Progress Than You Might Think…

woman in blue bikini bottom lying on blue textile

A recent visit to Armagh reminded me of the enduring legacy of one of this historic city’s most (in)famous inhabitants, James Ussher, father of the Ussher Chronology. The debate surrounding faith-based Creationism and Intelligent Design, in contrast to evidence-based evolutionary theory, has deep historical roots and continues to affect contemporary education and politics, especially in Northern Ireland. This piece examines the enduring legacy of James Ussher’s Chronology, the emergence of Young Earth Creationism, and the ongoing cultural and political conflicts …

Read more…

The Education Authority: Jobs for the Boys (and Girls)…

Back to School chalk

As of 2022, NI’s Education Authority (EA) has an annual budget of £2.3 billion, employs around 44,000 staff, and delivers vital services to approximately 1,100 schools—from school meals and transport to maintenance and special educational needs (SEN) support. Therefore, how this organisation is governed and who controls it has profound implications for hundreds of thousands of pupils, parents, and education professionals. Current Controversies Recent appointments to senior EA positions have once again raised concerns about political patronage and the need …

Read more…

The Resurgence of Democratic Deficiencies: Once More onto the Breach…

grayscale photo of woman doing silent hand sign

Described as “a great big gaping hole where public engagement with political processes should be”,[1] the term ‘democratic deficit’ gained currency in the UK following the introduction of the Local Government Act (1992).[2] This Act established the Local Government Commission for England (LGC), which was tasked with conducting a comprehensive review of local government. The LGC’s initial recommendations included reducing the number of locally elected councillors. This coincided with a reduced presence of councillors on the boards of public bodies, such as …

Read more…

O, wad some Power the giftie gie us: The clear need for reform of Northern Ireland’s school transfer process…

grayscale photo of people sitting on chair

The education system in Northern Ireland (NI), despite its reputation for academic excellence, faces significant challenges, particularly an urgent need to reform the school transfer process for 11-year-olds. This post will draw on local initiatives, international benchmarks, and human rights frameworks to explore persistent educational underachievement linked to socio-economic background, the impact of early academic selection, and low student life satisfaction on life chances. The focus will be on socio-economic divisions rather than religious segregation, hopefully contributing positively to the …

Read more…

Less heat, more light: surveillance, peace treaties, and bonfires…

close-up photo of fire at nighttime

The recent “industrial scale” data blunder by the Police Service of Northern Ireland has brought a renewed topicality to a piece of writing I set aside in the run-up to last May’s Local Government elections. Espionage has rarely been made so simple, but it is a practice as old as war itself. ‘Know your enemy’ is a key tenet of The Art of War, the magnum opus of Sun Tzu, a philosopher and general who lived through the tumultuous autumn …

Read more…

Segregation: an indulgence we can no longer afford?

a plane flying over a beach

It cannot have escaped the attention of anyone using our highways and byways on weekday mornings that with the summer holidays behind us, the dreaded school-run has resumed, with everything that brings with it. Estimates suggest that during the morning rush-hour, home-school travel accounts for 20% of the cars on Northern Ireland’s streets. And then there are the fleets of school buses that once again take to the roads, not to mention quite a few additional taxies! Apart from a …

Read more…

Facilitating Access to the Workplace: It’s the Economy, Stupid…

Do Something Great neon sign

A combination of factors, not least Brexit and Russia’s war in Ukraine, has contributed to the current cost-of-living crisis. However, economic turmoil and soaring inflation is also being fuelled by an unprecedented labour shortage. This is particularly true in Northern Ireland with its historically high proportion of those described as economically inactive – a socio-economic group aged 16 to 64 who were not working and not seeking or available to work. Things have not always been like this. It is …

Read more…

The Land of Shipbuilding Saints and Scholars: A Reflection on Ireland’s Maritime History

brown wooden ladder on green grass field under gray cloudy sky

The recent announcement that Harland & Wolff will once again produce ocean-going vessels comes as welcome news in a region steeped in maritime history. Belfast’s historic shipyard will perhaps remain most famous for building luxurious transatlantic liners for the White Star Line, including the Olympic-class trio – RMS Olympic, HMHS Britannic and, of course, RMS Titanic. If the medieval hagiographies are to be believed, however, these behemoths were far from the first vessels to leave Ireland’s shores bound for the …

Read more…

Public servants and secret societies: let there be light…

gold statue of a man

Politicians and archaeologists have had a long and interesting relationship with secret societies. Elias Ashmole, a founding Fellow of the Royal Society, was a politician, officer of arms, student of biology, astrology, and alchemy, and an antiquary. By any measure a polymath, he was also an early Freemason. Indeed, Ashmole’s initiation into the Lodge at Warrington in Lancashire in 1646 is the earliest known record of such a ceremony in England. Grand Lodges also eventually appeared in Ireland in 1725 …

Read more…

Social cohesion: can there be a united Ireland without a united Northern Ireland?

green grass and trees near river

Despite the current turmoil at Westminster or even the more mundane matter of the not unrelated cost-of-living crisis, the constitutional question is never far from being the main concern of many in Northern Ireland. But for at least the immediate future, would it not be better to reflect more on social cohesion than on geographic unity? Geopolitical regions are of course social constructs. They reflect certain perspectives and judgments in making particular groupings and, like every modern region, the social …

Read more…

Hard borders on the Island of Ireland are nothing new…

Hiking to the top of a rocky outcrop right before a heavy rain storm came in and caught the very last glimpse of sun making way through the clouds.My work is 100% community-supported. You can fund my next photography adventure at Patreon.com/rvrmakes

Half a billion years ago the land mass that makes up the island we recognise today as Ireland belonged to two primordial continents separated by an ancient ocean. The northern portion belonged to the continent of Laurentia, now preserved as parts of North American, while the south belonged to the supercontinent of Gondwana, which would form large parts of Europe, Africa, and Australia. About 470 million years ago, the process of plate tectonics caused these two ancient continents to drift …

Read more…

The Unheard Third, or the Non-Voting Prod…

Don't just take, give.

An Annex to ‘Voter Turnout Trends around the World’, a study published in 2016 by the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, tabulates the turnouts in the most recent parliamentary elections for 196 countries. The top 50 includes 14 democracies where voting is compulsory. These include Australia, 7th with a 93% voter turnout, and Belgium, 18th with 89%. There are also six South American countries where voting is compulsory, not all in the top 50. Three Scandinavian countries that …

Read more…

When Ballance Went a Long Way in Politics…

Despite a separation of almost 12,000 miles, Ireland and New Zealand share a significant number of defining cultural characteristics. Most obvious of these would be a common language, legal system, and parliamentary democracy, all the result of having been part of the British Empire. There is also a shared sporting legacy which recently saw Ireland celebrate its first-ever series win over the All Blacks. Like Ireland, New Zealand has a largely rural economy, famous not least for its lamb and …

Read more…

Do our representatives really represent us?

#LeaveNoOneBehind

Representative democracy, or indirect democracy, allows elected representatives to make decisions on the electorate’s behalf without further consultation. This system is efficient and, unlike direct democracy, does not require frequent referendums, relying instead on the representative to accurately reflect the views of their electorate. However, once elected, representatives can, with relative impunity, pursue their own agendas and vote according to their own beliefs. They might even choose to change party midterm. Representative democracy can, therefore, result in a lack of …

Read more…

1798, a cross-community rebellion…

The return of inflation, a fuel crisis, strikes and recession, together with Russia’s invasion of a neighbouring state, all to the soundtrack of a resurgent Swedish pop group, has prompted many to ask if this is the 1970s all over again. However, some striking parallels with today’s problems can be found almost 200 years earlier, in the 1790s, with a cost-of-living crisis, climate change, unpopular wars and, to add a particularly local flavour, constitutional upheaval and sectarian strife. So, in …

Read more…

The past made present: the relevance of historical statecraft…

Basement of Diocletian's Palace, circa 295 CE. Split, Croatia, February, 21 2022

Are there lessons to be learned from history regarding the impact on junior partners following the fragmentation of monolithic powers and the realignment of geopolitical relations or, to put it another way, what have the Romans ever done for us? Given that they never felt inclined to invade the remote island to the west of Britain they called the Land of Winter, the extent of any Roman influence felt in Hibernia must have remained relatively limited. It certainly would not …

Read more…

Frictionless passage in Prehistory…

The implementation of the Northern Ireland Protocol has focused attention on present and future trading relations between this and other regions of the United Kingdom and the European Union. However, a brief reflection on the movement of goods in the past might help bring perspective to the debate. In the words of George Santayana, “those who fail to learn from the mistakes of their predecessors are destined to repeat them.” Long before the launch of the first Larne-Cairnryan ferry, the …

Read more…