“it’s up to the Executive whether to sell assets like Belfast harbour”

The Northern Ireland Executive met today [To decide what planet they’re living on? – Ed] to discuss the outcome of the 2010 Spending Review.  Apparently, they now want to meet with either the “Coalition Government” or the “London Government”.  In their statement they can’t decide which. Perhaps the UK Government would do?  How about the Northern Ireland Secretary of State?  He is a member of that government, after all. And as the NI Secretary of State, Owen Paterson, told the BBC “This is …

Read more…

Cries of betrayal over funding will not help

Peter Robinson and Martin McGuinness were hardly in the ideal place to respond the spending cuts, sending cries of betrayal down the line from the States that an agreement for £18 billion of funding struck with Gordon Brown had not been honoured. On that one, the dogs in the streets were barking doubts long ago. It all seemed too good to be true – at least in  the version according to Peter and Martin.  Investment promises just do not override …

Read more…

“More tea, Eamon?”

In the Irish Times Miriam Lord has a ‘fly-on-the-wall’ report from the main Irish political parties’ consensus meeting yesterday on the budgetary measures needed to get the economic situation under control.  From the Irish Times The Taoiseach has an idea. “Right lads. Boutros Boutros Gormley wants harmony. I’ll sing the verses and you two can join in on the chorus. What’ll we sing?” They start to snigger when they think of Gerry Adams locked outside in the cold. (Although this …

Read more…

Owen Paterson: “I don’t know what planet they’re living on.”

That was Northern Ireland Secretary of State Owen Paterson’s reported response to the reaction of our special little pleaders to the outcome of the UK Government’s 2010 Spending Review.  And he has a point. The NI First Minister, the DUP’s Peter Robinson, claimed the cuts were ‘worse than feared’ . But his party colleague, and NI Finance Minister, Sammy Wilson, has stated that “Whilst the level of budget reductions we are facing is unwelcome, and will present a serious challenge, it comes as …

Read more…

Irish Times: “For Ireland’s political class the prospect of another [EU] treaty referendum is nightmarish”

Whether the European Commission succeeds in introducing its proposed directly levied EU taxes, including a possible EU-wide value-added tax (VAT), in the face of opposition from a number of national governments, remains to be seen. But we’re still looking at interesting EU times ahead… In agreeing new sanctions for countries in breach of EU budgetary rules, France and Germany are now calling for a permanent bail-out facility for Eurozone countries, before the current one expires in 2013. As the Irish Times reports …

Read more…

“There can be no greater endorsement of our world class skills and knowledge base…”

I’d welcome Peter Robinson’s call to end state-funding of faith-based schools if I thought he was serious about separating church and state. But he’s just as unlikely now, as he was then, to intervene whenever a supernaturalist Minister attempts to influence what’s on display in our museums, or at our World Heritage site, or in schools within the Lurgan District Council area. And what is Sinn Féin’s position on the DUP leader’s de-segregated objective? The Northern Ireland deputy First Minister, Sinn Féin’s …

Read more…

A plan for parental choice – the route to transformation

  “This is typical Peter Robinson,” said Ms Ritchie. “On the one hand he says the most visionary thing ever said by a DUP politician about our divided society, and then he spoils it with an old-fashioned political sideswipe at Catholic schools. “He is still right that we should aim for a future where our children are increasingly educated together – but blaming Catholics for the division is shameful and totally the wrong place to start.”   OK, so there’s …

Read more…

Robinson: “This will test the enthusiasm of the Executive for making savings in local government.”

As Brian has already noted, Northern Ireland First Minister, the DUP’s Peter Robinson, has set out his views on the desirability of a “single educational system” here.  As, previously, did the NI Secretary of State.  We’ll wait to see if the deputy First Minister is still “all for it”. But in his speech Peter Robinson also tackled some of Sinn Féin’s recent economic proposals. From the DUP leader’s speech Another red herring thrown across the debate to deflect attention from the issue …

Read more…

“However we can’t invite ourselves…”

Northern Ireland deputy First Minister, Sinn Fein’s Martin McGuinness, was quick to claim a victory for OFMDFM’s “united case” after NI Secretary of State Owen Paterson said “Having had discussions with the treasury, we are confident that having spent £9.8bn since 2005, that by 2017-18, we will be on track for Northern Ireland to have spent £18bn.” But economist John Simpson was already looking at the potential small print Economist John Simpson told the BBC that he believed a total of £14bn will …

Read more…

Cowen: “I believe the pursuit of the national interest and the common good must have priority”

With Sinn Féin proposing some more taxes and borrowing here, it’s worth looking at what’s been happening there. On Saturday 9th October RTÉ noted Taoiseach Brian Cowen’s intial lukewarm response to Green Party leader John Gormley’s call for an all-party consensus on a four-year budget plan. Taoiseach Brian Cowen has said he would welcome a political consensus on the budgetary measures needed to get the economic situation under control. However, he said it was up to the Opposition parties to put …

Read more…

Fact-checking Sinn Féin’s economic proposals for Northern Ireland

While John wants alternatives, let’s have a closer look at what Sinn Féin’s ‘blue-sky thinking’ has actually resulted in.  And how the figures, where given, stack up against the ‘can save £1.9bn’ headline. Here is the list of SF’s economic proposals Introduce tax varying and borrowing powers to enable the Executive to generate income and stimulate development. That’s top of the list.  It’s not costed and there’s no indication of what ‘varying’ they propose to do. Implement the Review of Public Administration …

Read more…

There is a Better Way? Is there?

This morning, Sinn Féin launched it’s proposals for, essentially, raising revenues rather than making cuts. While there will be the usual knee-jerk dismissal in many quarters, they have at least published their strategy (which can be read here). Some cuts are being suggested, including a 15% pay cut for Stormont salaries, an end to renumeration of committee chairs plus a pay freeze for higher paid civil servants. Implementing the RPA with the projected cost savings of 400m is also included, …

Read more…

Translink: “a great set of results”

That was Translink’s Ciaran Rogan’s response to the customer satisfaction survey which rated high overall satisfaction levels amongst Translink passengers.  I don’t think they asked those who ‘walked the plank’ on the Dublin to Belfast train today… But the survey also revealed 2.5 million fewer journeys taken by the public compared to last year – down from 80.7 million in 2008/09 to 78.2 million in 2009/10.  From the BBC report Ryan Simpson, Senior Consumer Affairs Officer at the Consumer Council, welcomed the …

Read more…

TUC and ICTU oppose lower Corporation Tax for Northern Ireland

Interesting to note ICTU Deputy General Secretary Peter Bunting, now sitting on that interim NI Water Board, welcoming a TUC report critical of attempts to lower corporation tax here.  From the Belfast Telegraph report ICTU Deputy General Secretary Peter Bunting said: “This paper should once and for all lay to rest the argument by some vested interests in Northern Ireland that a low corporation tax regime would assist economic growth for all, as opposed to private profit for the few.” As …

Read more…

The cuts: another straw in the wind?

The Guardian’s most centrist commentator Martin Kettle argues that  the First Minsters’ case  for leniency is one of the signs that the cuts mightn’t  live up to their fierce billing. Or is  being panglossian, as he himself wonders? Extracts  Might it not instead be time for the long expected political hurricane to be cautiously downgraded to a tropical storm? Here are three very current reasons for thinking the answer is yes. The first is this week’s report in the Financial Times that …

Read more…

Spending cuts prompt Peter’s move on political reform. Will it work?

So Peter is moving on this at last. What’s not clear is his next move other than into thin air.  Cutting the sizes of the overblown Assembly and Executive is an appropriate  aim with additional political motives. It follows on the  proposed reduction of Westminster seats and Stormont constituencies to 15 and the reduction by one of the MLAs in each constituency. Peter’s timing suggests he has given up on getting agreement with SF and the other parties  behind the scenes. Or …

Read more…

Whitehall ” too busy ” to deal with First Ministers – claim

 The fairly dismissive  Verdict of my colleague, devolution expert Alan Trench, on the rainbow coalition of FMs’ call to scale down the cuts.  But note the flier in the FT that the phasing may be changed in a direction they favour. Adds Friday. Warm words from deputy PM Nick Clegg about the likely impact of the cuts  on a familiarisation visit. Extracts: The First Minister and Deputy First Minister raised with me in very clear terms their concerns about the …

Read more…

“Ireland and Greece have no choice than ‘to do fairly dramatic things in as clear a manner as possible’.”

The BBC notes that credit rating agency Fitch have downgraded Ireland’s credit rating from AA- to A+ citing the recently announced cost of rescuing the Irish banking system. RTÉ adds The agency said it was cutting the rating to ‘A+’ from ‘AA-‘ due to what it called the greater than expected costs associated with the Government’s recapitalisation of the Irish banks, especially Anglo Irish Bank. The agency has put a negative outlook on the rating, meaning a further downgrade is …

Read more…

NI Environment Minister’s “retreat from Moscow”

I mentioned that the public inquiry into the John Lewis development at Sprucefield has been delayed due to legal concerns about comments made by the NI Environment Minister, the DUP’s Edwin Poots.  The BBC reports that Lord Justice Girvan has asked the Attorney General to consider contempt of court proceedings, despite a statement from the Minister being read out in court today.  And, it would appear, not just in regard to the Minister.  From the BBC report Lord Justice Girvan said [the Minister’s statement in court today] did not “sit …

Read more…

“with nothing less than Irish economic sovereignty on the line”

Another informative entry from the Irish Times‘ Arthur Beesley’s European Diary.  If you were wondering what the European Commission has in mind for those problem PIIGS, including Ireland, you could try the EU economic and monetary affairs commissioner Olli Rehn’s recommended reading…  From the Irish Times As the cost of the banking bailout approaches €50 billion, general government debt is set to rise to 98.6 per cent of GDP this year. As recently as 2007, it was 25 per cent.The upshot is that Ahern’s …

Read more…