What ‘Before the Vote’ gets right and wrong about the centre ground…

John Doyle’s Before the Vote treats the centre ground as the group most likely to decide a referendum on Irish unity. On the constitution, he is right that Alliance’s voters are divided: in the October poll, they and Green voters were more undecided than voters for any other party. He is less careful about the size of the centre, and he does not examine what would happen to his argument if undecided voters moved to parties that have a constitutional position. LucidTalk’s poll for the Belfast Telegraph, taken online from 29 to 31 October with a weighted sample of about 1,050, suggests that this may be happening: Alliance is losing support, and more than two-thirds of respondents who voted Alliance in 2022 but now favour another party name the SDLP or Sinn Féin. The movement matters for Alliance because the Irish government has proposed a study of constitutional futures and intends to invite every party to contribute.

What Doyle gets right

Doyle compares three surveys of Alliance voters’ views on unity. The 2022 Northern Ireland Assembly Election Study and the 2024 ARINS poll each found 42% for remaining in the UK, with 29% and 31% for unity. LucidTalk in 2025 found 21% for the UK, 33% for unity and 46% undecided (pp. 132–133). He concludes that Alliance voters are divided roughly evenly between the three positions and are not, as was once assumed, simply moderate supporters of the Union (p. 133). He also argues that the currently undecided will determine the outcome (p. 133) and that middle-ground voters are likely to be decisive in any referendum held in the next ten years (p. 217).

The October poll supports both points. Among respondents who reported voting Alliance in 2022, 37% would vote for unity in a referendum held now, 20% would vote to remain in the UK and 43% are undecided but would vote. Only Green voters come close, at 42% undecided; among SDLP voters the figure is 20%.

A second question, on longer-term aspiration, shows how open these voters are.

Longer-term constitutional aspiration

Only 9% of these respondents say they want Northern Ireland to remain in the UK now and in the future. The other answers are not all support for change. A respondent who might support unity in 20 years has made no commitment to vote for it, and the 9% who are unsure may yet favour the Union. Few of these voters have ruled unity out.

What he gets wrong

Doyle’s figures for the size of the centre are inconsistent. On p. 126 he gives Alliance’s 2022 vote as 15.4 per cent. His own Table 6.3 (p. 128) gives Alliance 13.53 per cent and a combined Alliance and Green “centre total” of 15.43 per cent. On p. 136 he refers to “the 16 per cent voting for Alliance”. On p. 135 the same 16 per cent is the share voting for parties designated as “other” in the Assembly, a group that includes People Before Profit, which supports a united Ireland; on p. 137 it is the share voting for parties “without a declared policy position”. The differences are small, but his estimate of the referendum balance (p. 137) depends on how large the middle is.

A more consequential gap concerns where those voters will be when a referendum is called. Doyle describes the centre ground as having grown from about 9 per cent to 15 per cent over 25 years (p. 135) and calls Alliance supporters “the decisive ‘swing voters’” in any unity referendum (p. 217). He also argues that election results, read as the balance between unionist and nationalist parties plus transfers from parties without a constitutional position, may provide the most robust evidence of when a poll should be called, and offers that as a guide for the Secretary of State (p. 138). Schedule 1 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 requires a poll if it appears likely to the Secretary of State that a majority would vote for unity, and says nothing about what evidence to use. He does not examine what that evidence would show if constitutionally undecided voters moved to parties that have a position. The October poll puts Alliance at 9% and the Greens at 4%, a combined 13%, against 15% in 2022. It also shows where reported 2022 Alliance voters now say they would vote.

Where 2022 Alliance voters say they would vote now

Excluding don’t knows, 30% of these respondents would now vote SDLP or Sinn Féin, almost five times the 6% who would vote for a unionist party. The figures rest on 845 respondents before weighting and a weighted base of 139, and LucidTalk publishes no margin of error for this group.

Electoral movement and constitutional preference are separate questions. The poll does not ask why voters moved, and its tables do not show whether those moving to the SDLP and Sinn Féin are the same respondents who favour unity. A voter who leaves Alliance for the SDLP may remain undecided on the border. On Doyle’s preferred measure, which counts votes by party, that voter now counts on the nationalist side of the election balance. The number of undecided voters could stay the same while the parties that represent them change, and an election-based test could then read that movement as growing support for unity.

Alliance’s record

Doyle credits Naomi Long with positioning Alliance as a party that supports the Good Friday Agreement without promoting a position for or against unity (p. 135). In March 2022 Long told BBC Sunday Politics, as reported in the Irish Times, that when Alliance took a position, “as undoubtedly will happen at some point in the future”, it would be based on facts and evidence. In October 2022 the party’s then deputy leader, Stephen Farry, told a Seanad committee that Alliance would take part in constitutional dialogue “on a without-prejudice basis”, and that its party council would consider whether to give members a free vote.

In February 2025 Long said the party might “step back” from a referendum campaign and treat it as a matter of conscience, “an option that’s always been open”, adding that “the first decision is whether or not to take a position”. In the same interview she said Alliance was “willing to engage in those discussions about the future of the UK and about the future shape of Ireland”. Eight months later she told the BBC’s Borderland podcast that the Secretary of State should set out the criteria for calling a poll, arguing that without them “every single election becomes a kind of proxy for a border poll”.

The party’s MLAs set out the same approach in the Assembly in May 2026, when Alliance tabled an amendment, in Eóin Tennyson’s name, to an SDLP motion on constitutional change. It would have removed the motion’s reference to polling showing “majority support for a new Ireland” and affirmed instead the Agreement’s process for deciding the constitutional question, together with a commitment to a shared future through good government and democratic renewal. The amendment fell by 43 votes to 16. Alliance’s 16 MLAs then abstained on the motion, which fell by 34 votes to 33.

Alliance’s last two manifestos, for the 2022 Assembly election and the 2024 Westminster election, say nothing about preparation for a referendum, and neither do Long’s 2026 conference speech or the party’s May 2026 paper, Democratic Renewal. The 2022 manifesto commits the party to ending the designation system and to North-South and East-West infrastructure cooperation. The 2024 manifesto proposes closer North-South and East-West cooperation, supports Shared Island funding and calls for a UK-wide convention to codify the UK constitution. Long’s March 2026 conference speech mentions the constitution only to set it aside, saying most people do not go to sleep worried about the border. Alliance’s May 2026 paper, Democratic Renewal, sets out reforms to Stormont and calls on the UK and Irish governments to drive them as co-guarantors of the Agreement. It is a paper on institutional reform and does not cover the whole programme, but its only constitutional proposal is the same UK-wide convention.

Two separate initiatives have since come from Dublin, one from the Taoiseach and one from the Tánaiste’s party, Fine Gael. At the end of October the Taoiseach announced plans for a body to research constitutional futures, and on 3 November he gave his parliamentary party more detail of what he called a Futures Study Initiative. It would examine three scenarios: a unitary republic governed mainly from Dublin; an all-island state with devolved government in Northern Ireland; and continued cooperation under the Good Friday Agreement without constitutional change. A recognised independent figure would lead it, with a secretariat in the Department of the Taoiseach, and each political party and activist group would be invited to make submissions. It has been proposed, not yet established. On 14 November RTÉ reported that the Tánaiste had written to party leaders north and south, Long among them, asking for their views on Fine Gael’s unity blueprint. The SDLP has welcomed both approaches. Long answered the Tánaiste’s letter on 15 November, telling BBC Sunday Politics that Alliance would take part “without prejudice to how we might decide the constitutional question”, adding: “We’re not there to be advocates for change or advocates for the status quo, but we will engage constructively.”

Is Alliance in a position to adapt?

Long’s 2025 remarks on a conscience vote can be read as a retreat, but the record shows a shift of emphasis within options the party had already set out. In 2022 Long expected Alliance to take a position, while Farry told the Seanad committee that a free vote was under consideration. By 2025 Long was describing the second option as one that “kind of makes sense”. The position suits a divided electorate and a divided membership: in a survey of Alliance members for Jonathan Tonge and colleagues’ study of the party, 38% said they would vote for unity in a border poll held within the next decade, 28% would vote to remain in the UK, 4% would abstain and 30% did not know.

A party can stay neutral on how its members vote and still work on the terms of the choice: how a poll is triggered, what each option would mean and how Northern Ireland would be governed under each. Long’s call for published criteria is work of the first kind. She has also argued for the second and third. In an interview for Tonge and colleagues’ study, published in 2024, she said Alliance was there “to advocate for informed and intelligent discourse” so that any vote would be an informed decision, and called for “more academically led discourse around what the consequences of change would be”, naming pensions, rights and the future of the Agreement’s structures. None of those four documents takes that work forward. In February 2025, Long also said the party could decide at the outset “we’re not going to engage at a formal level as a party in this debate”. She was speaking about a referendum campaign. The Futures Study Initiative, as proposed, separates that campaign from the preparation that comes before it, and its independent, evidence-based design is close to the kind of work Long described. Since 2025, she has said Alliance will take part in discussions of both futures, and repeated it on 15 November, so the open question is what it will contribute.

That separation gives Alliance something to contribute, because it already has relevant policy. Doyle argues that middle-ground voters will hold a strong bargaining position, and that Alliance would be likely to oppose any future system built on designation as Irish, British or other (pp. 216–217). Democratic Renewal proposes ending designations, a commitment already in the 2022 manifesto, and replacing cross-community votes with weighted majorities. Those proposals bear directly on two of the three scenarios: a devolved Northern Ireland within a united Ireland, and continued devolution within the UK. Alliance could submit them to the initiative, if it is established, without endorsing any outcome.

Long’s 2026 conference speech treated the constitution as a distraction from delivery. That is a defensible message to voters who want Stormont to work, but it sits less easily with the poll’s evidence that, among respondents who reported voting Alliance in 2022, 43% are undecided on a referendum held now and only 9% want Northern Ireland to remain in the UK now and in the future. A University of Liverpool survey of 2024 Westminster voters found that 63% of Alliance voters thought a border poll should be held within the next two decades. It also fits poorly with an initiative that, if established, would ask every party for its proposals.

Limits of the evidence

The October figures come from a single poll, and LucidTalk’s own earlier figures put definite support for unity among Alliance voters at 33% in 2025, so some of the change since may be sampling variation. Results also depend on the question and on which voters are counted: the Liverpool survey, of 2024 Westminster voters, offered no undecided option and found 68% of Alliance voters favoured remaining in the UK as a long-term policy and 31% favoured reunification. The tables break voters down by their 2022 vote, so they cannot show how current Alliance voters, or those who have left, would vote on the border. The poll gives no reasons for anyone’s choices. The account of Alliance’s position draws on published statements and the four documents named above; the party may have done work on preparation that it has not published.

Conclusion

Doyle is right that the centre is divided and that undecided voters may decide a referendum. His account does not examine what happens if those voters move to parties with a declared constitutional position, although the election evidence he prefers would register that movement. The October poll suggests it may already be under way: Alliance is losing support, and more than two-thirds of its 2022 voters who now favour another party name the SDLP or Sinn Féin. The poll does not show why they moved or whether their constitutional preferences have changed.

Alliance can respond without choosing a side, and Long has already asked for evidence on what change would mean. The Futures Study Initiative, as proposed, would invite every party to contribute, and Alliance’s own reform proposals bear on two of its three scenarios. Long has now said that Alliance will engage with Fine Gael’s proposals; whether it contributes to the Taoiseach’s separate initiative remains to be seen. What Alliance contributes will show whether a party neutral on the outcome will help define the choice its voters may face.

Sources:

John Doyle, Before the Vote: Planning for a United Ireland (Dublin: DCU Press, 2026), pp. 126, 128, 132–133, 135–138, 216–217.

LucidTalk/Belfast Telegraph Autumn 2026 Tracker Poll, data tables, version 4.4 (11 November 2026): MAINPollQuestion1, Q6 and Q6c, by 2022 Assembly vote.

Newton Emerson, Northern Ireland’s future will be decided by rising tide of Alliance voters, Irish Times, 10 March 2022: quotes Long’s remarks on BBC Sunday Politics.

Houses of the Oireachtas, Seanad Public Consultation Committee, 14 October 2022: evidence from Stephen Farry.

David Young (PA), Alliance not taking position in border poll campaign may make sense, says Naomi Long, Irish News, 27 February 2025.

BBC News, Clarity needed on border poll process, says Naomi Long (syndicated by AOL), October 2025: remarks to the BBC Borderland podcast.

Northern Ireland Assembly, Motion: Change on these Islands, 18 May 2026: motion, Amendment 1 and divisions.

Fiona Murray (BBC News NI), Alliance will engage ‘without prejudice’ on Irish unity – Long, BBC News, 15 November 2026: remarks on BBC Sunday Politics.

Alliance Party, Together We Can: Assembly manifesto 2022 (CAIN copy).

Alliance Party, Alliance Leading Change for Everyone: Westminster manifesto 2024 (CAIN copy).

Alliance Party, Naomi Long, Conference Speech 2026 (14 March 2026).

Alliance Party, Democratic Renewal: A plan to reform Stormont and fix our broken politics (May 2026).

IrishCentral, report on the Taoiseach’s plans for a constitutional futures body, 30 October 2026: covers his 28 October speech and his Irish Times interview.

RTÉ News, Taoiseach tells party of plan for Futures Study Initiative, 3 November 2026.

Northern Ireland Act 1998, Schedule 1, paragraph 2.

RTÉ News, Tánaiste seeks views on Irish unity from party leaders, 14 November 2026.

Irish News, Nationalist leaders welcome Taoiseach’s plans for new Irish unity body.

Jon Tonge and Ben Rosher, Voter insights from the 2024 Northern Ireland General Election Survey (University of Liverpool), Tables 31–32, pp. 22–23: fieldwork July to September 2024, 2,034 respondents, 189 Alliance voters.

Jonathan Tonge, Máire Braniff, Thomas Hennessey, James W. McAuley, Clare Rice and Sophie A. Whiting, The Alliance Party of Northern Ireland: Beyond Unionism and Nationalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2024), ISBN 978-0-19-288958-4, ch. 6, “The constitutional question” (ProQuest ebook, pp. 129–148): Table 6.3 (n = 793) and Long’s interview.

 


Discover more from Slugger O'Toole

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

We are reader supported. Donate to keep Slugger lit!

For over 20 years, Slugger has been an independent place for debate and new ideas. We have published over 40,000 posts and over one and a half million comments on the site. Each month we have over 70,000 readers. All this we have accomplished with only volunteers we have never had any paid staff.

Slugger does not receive any funding, and we respect our readers, so we will never run intrusive ads or sponsored posts. Instead, we are reader-supported. Help us keep Slugger independent by becoming a friend of Slugger. While we run a tight ship and no one gets paid to write, we need money to help us cover our costs.

If you like what we do, we are asking you to consider giving a monthly donation of any amount, or you can give a one-off donation. Any amount is appreciated.