Church at the Crossroads conference…

Flags never fed anyone – as has been famously said. Identity symbols that both bring together and keep one ‘Imagined community’ apart from its ‘other.’

But when culture — or even kinetic war — becomes a sport without restraining rules or referees, we enter a darker space: the search for light existential.

Such was the context of the Church at the Crossroads conference in The Assembly Buildings Belfast on 14-15th November – its purpose was to hear the oft-forgotten stories and insights of Palestinian Christians – caught in a crucible that puts our local difficulties into perspective.

Their cry? To be heard by the often cloth-eared Western church.

The previous day, its opening speaker, Professor Salim Munayer, from occupied East Jerusalem, was driven round parts of the city. Through territorial boundaries now also marked with Israeli and Palestinian colours.

‘I feel I’m at home,’ he said after decades of reconciliation work.

When the First Intifada (of Palestinian youth) erupted in the West Bank in 1987, the Israeli security establishment wanted to avoid what they termed the ‘Belfastisation’ of the conflict – resulting in routine civic disorder. Inter-state conflicts were easier to manage – but when it became Intercommunal, between Israeli and Palestinian, that was not in their interests. For where the conflict lies, there must also be the solution.

Something that cannot resolve without Justice. Something that energised myriad Hebrew Prophets.

Something Salim, after a lifetime of peace-making, seeks still. Even as his Jewish settler neighbour (now no longer an outlier) barks at him every time he sees him. Because Salim’s an animal in his eyes.

The result of decades of dehumanisation that erodes restraint, lowers, or rather, removes the bar.

An American Minister revisiting Ramallah and Bethlehem this summer witnessed that dehumanisation up close.

Desperation amid the plethora of checkpoints, barriers, or turnstiles needing navigation by local Palestinians  – to get to work. Or visit family. Long lines slow-funnelled into processing points. ‘Security Barriers’ on steroids.

As they were herded through, one local turned to him to say, ‘We don’t need Human Rights representatives here – we need Animal Rights Reps.’

‘Desperation everywhere,’ reported our American cousin.

The same desperation as evidenced in the quieter Conference moments. Of a people in survival mode, holding on by the slenderest of fingertips. Traumatised daily by fear of their children being beaten by settlers.

Or worse, arrested, spirited away without charge. Disappeared into a Gulag of prisons. Placed in often unending ‘Administrative Detention.’ Tortured, starved, refused medical attention or visitation. Resulting recently in a 16-year-old boy being reduced to a dead husk within six months. A torture then transferred to the family. With remains held, sometimes for years.

Animal rights would be an upgrade.

Later, Rev Munther Isaac recalls his son pleading, ‘Can we please leave? I don’t want soldiers coming to our house.’ Part of a history stretching back to 1948 and an Acre catastrophe for another contributor’s family. Where theologian Tony Deik’s grandmother died after drinking water from a well poisoned by Jewish Militias. Recently released archival records reveal this as widespread policy. A required ‘thinning out’ of Arab Palestinians within the borders of the newly declared state. Through Operation ‘Cast your Bread on the Waters.’ A scriptural quote where the second part of the sentence was, ‘and good shall return to you.’ The inverse invoked.

In response, Christian Palestinians have always advocated non-violent resistance to an occupation intent on subjugation, encouraging migration. Many Christian families with their wider networks of international contacts increasingly seek civilised survival elsewhere. Their presence further ‘thinned out.’

But some remain. To study, teach, minister. Some even sketch the contours of a renewed theology of martyrdom: for the descendants of the ‘First Church,’ abandoned by a Western Ecclesia, turning away in awkward silences over compromised allegiances, seemingly entranced by what Naomi Klein terms a strange ‘End Times Fascism’.

Replacing the ‘Map’ laid out by an unlicensed Galilean Rabbi in his advocacy of wellbeing from a certain Mount: through the reverencing of mercy, of peace-making, and of those hungering and thirsting for the right.

From start to finish, ‘Church at the Crossroads’ enunciated those deeply humane values before a truly ecumenical audience.

Some things can’t be wrapped in a flag.


Discover more from Slugger O'Toole

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

We are reader supported. Donate to keep Slugger lit!

For over 20 years, Slugger has been an independent place for debate and new ideas. We have published over 40,000 posts and over one and a half million comments on the site. Each month we have over 70,000 readers. All this we have accomplished with only volunteers we have never had any paid staff.

Slugger does not receive any funding, and we respect our readers, so we will never run intrusive ads or sponsored posts. Instead, we are reader-supported. Help us keep Slugger independent by becoming a friend of Slugger. While we run a tight ship and no one gets paid to write, we need money to help us cover our costs.

If you like what we do, we are asking you to consider giving a monthly donation of any amount, or you can give a one-off donation. Any amount is appreciated.