Manchán Magan’s ‘Oddballs: A Novel of Affections’: Book Review

magan oddballs A skilled chronicler in travel narratives and documentaries of those who wander the fringes, Manchán Magan’s debut novel follows four characters on the fringe. Two of them, teenaged Rachel and her quasi-aunt Charlotte, collide after a long estrangement in New Hampshire, and take off on Charlotte’s Wiccan pilgrimage to ye olde England of, as a bemused or bitter Rachel puts it, ‘Merlin and Voldemort’. After a few detours, they wind up on a quasi-borrowed yacht that lands them off Co Kerry. There, in the village of Reek, they meet Colm and Dónal, two brothers with their own tension.

Magan, as a bilingual writer and observer of the Irish-language communities, sprinkles sentences of Gaeilge to show the divide between the elderly and the youth, as English supplants the fading speech of the home, school, and church. He touches lightly on the gap, but he pins down the malaise that afflicts natives such as Colm and Dónal. For the former, unstable mentally, he cannot fit in to the small space where he avoids interactions with his neighbors. He yearns for release. Watching a crayfish pot bob, it mimics him. ‘It was caught in a loop now, and kept going back and forth, clanging each time until the thin batons of the hazel basket were in pieces and only the lead-grey buoy remained’. (20)

For the latter, he resents having to sing for his supper ‘to play the happy leprechaun for dimwit tourists’ at the ‘jigs and reels show’ at the local pub. He reflects at dawn as he looks over the ascetic expanse, the empty valley around Reek, down on soaked German campers. ‘To them it was idyllic, a haven from their fraught lives; to him it was a rope, a slowly tightening noose’. (111)

Into the brothers’ eccentric or scant routines respectively, Rachel and Charlotte stumble ashore. Rachel, a ‘cutter’ after the death of her boyfriend Nathaniel, broods. Carving out his name below her navel, another joins it above. ‘God had hurt the most as there was less flesh there’. (36) Hobbled by an injury during her college track career, she finds herself unhappily tethered to Charlotte, who has her own troubled past to contend with. A determined witch, she suspects other women to share her purported powers, and she bristles at the conspiracy of maternal silence and patriarchal pain around her. As she warns Rachel whom she regards as a sister practitioner: ‘It’s why we’re all addicted to makeup now, we want to hide the blemishes’. (79)

Magan, no stranger given his journalism to introverted paths less traveled, sharpens his wit and quickens the pace once he sets what starts off as a slow tale into motion, after Rachel and Charlotte cross the ocean. ‘Sagely take heed and remove your noises from our seas, we plead’. So channels the girl assuming the oracular medium as Charlotte and Rachel get drawn within an English New Age circle. ‘I am of the council of dolphin breath, honoured to be invited to share amongst you this day’. (100-101)

I expected much more of such satire, but this 2010 novel unfolds through a kitten’s funeral, a cliffside revelation, and encounters of mutual recognition, into a more poignant depiction of marginal people. As Charlotte realizes: ‘There had to be a Canada in the realms beyond; every universe needs its Canada’.(234) That is, a place for spiritual liberation, a border to cross into a place less heavy for those among us so frail. Speaking of frontiers, a few clunky non-Americanisms for his American pair’s speech aside, and a few typos, detract little from the grace that increasingly infuses a lightly sketched tale about darker, incised moods, and the possibility of gradual, dogged renewal.

Discover more from Slugger O'Toole

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

We are reader supported. Donate to keep Slugger lit!

For over 20 years, Slugger has been an independent place for debate and new ideas. We have published over 40,000 posts and over one and a half million comments on the site. Each month we have over 70,000 readers. All this we have accomplished with only volunteers we have never had any paid staff.

Slugger does not receive any funding, and we respect our readers, so we will never run intrusive ads or sponsored posts. Instead, we are reader-supported. Help us keep Slugger independent by becoming a friend of Slugger. While we run a tight ship and no one gets paid to write, we need money to help us cover our costs.

If you like what we do, we are asking you to consider giving a monthly donation of any amount, or you can give a one-off donation. Any amount is appreciated.