Jack Gallagher grew up a in a working class area of East Belfast, not far from what is now an interface area with the Short Strand area. He describes himself as a ‘small u’ unionist, and voted against the Belfast Agreement in the 1998 referendum.
What values are protected under the Union with Britain that would be under threat in a political unification of the island?
I don�t anticipate that there will be a unification of Ireland. Unionists have never felt comfortable with the Republic of Ireland attitude to education or to the Protestant religion and one would feel that there still exists within the Roman Catholic church the very strong desire to control the religious thinking of what they regard as Irish people, myself included.
How does Unionism differ from Republicanism or Nationalism?
If you were a Republican in the general sense of the word, you would believe in the separation of church and state. You would be strongly in favour of the separation of the church from the education system and yet here in Northern Ireland you have a separate education system for Catholics fully supported by the state. That doesn�t happen in America. It�s all right if Catholic people want to be educated separately I would support their right to do that, but it�s just an example of an ambivalence in Republican thinking. Nationalists at least weathered the steps and did not pay lip service to democracy. Republicans would seem to want to expunge every vestige of Britishness from the island of Ireland. They don�t seem to be concerned about creating conditions in which there could be a pluralist and a democratic inclusive society. They say stuff like that but their actions always seem to be totally the opposite. Almost as if they want to deny history or change history, or re-write history.
Can you see any examples of that?
They are making an issue about Londonderry and if you carried that to its logical conclusion, you would go back to the original names for everything. When they say Brits out, they don�t mean the British Army out, they mean everybody who�s British out. This is the 21st century and people have voted time and time again in a free vote. Even Republicans, there would never have been a time in Ireland since 1921 when there was not North and South of the border a reasonably democratic, equal, political means of asserting that your view in anything. There was the Dail and there was Stormont. People may not have agreed with your view but the opportunity to assert your view politically has always been there for Republicans on an absolutely equal basis with Protestants and Unionists. So to have gone the length of developing a military campaign to change things, to kill people as an act of strategy, to set bombs in place to advance a strategic objective by killing and maiming people has driven people further apart.
What would you say to a Nationalist who might say the old Stormont regime was simply a permanent government facing a permanent opposition – resulting in permanent stand off?
I think the Anglo-Irish Agreement and the Belfast Agreement ratified that. They decided that there is an enormous division and it�s never going to change so they manage it on the basis that that division exists. In my view once you�ve established that you have a system of government that is encouraging those attitudes. I can recall the early �60�s and the feeling that change was taking place all over Europe and things were moving forward, and the whole European community notion and you could have visualised the evolution of community government for the province. You could have visualised the concept of responsibility being generally acceptable.
What do you see as an alternative to the Belfast Agreement?
Unionism has to develop a strategy for a Northern Ireland, which is about community government, responsibility sharing and fair and equitable government for everyone. It�s an optimistic view but we are more likely to find peace in that direction than any other. It would be possible for Nationalists and Unionists to unite in a common vision of a Northern Ireland that was set up to maximise people�s satisfactions.
What would the constituent elements of such a Unionist vision be?
We are a constituent part of Europe so all the European laws and all the European conditions of living apply here. Rights guaranteed to European citizens are applied here, and people have equal access to the Courts. You have a United Kingdom government, which is required to deliver all its citizens equal rights and opportunities.
How important is religion to the Ulster Unionist identity?
Ulster Unionism may once have been all about Protestant identity. Personally I don�t think that�s there any more. I don�t think that people in the Orange Order should be involved in the Unionist Party, even though the Unionist Party grew out of the Orange Order. A Unionist Party that wants to articulate a broader kind of vision will have to be one that does not have connections with specifically religious organisations and nor indeed should anybody else. I don�t think religious conviction is the driving engine in terms of people�s political thinking. It�s a much more political situation now.
So a broader vision will allow Northern Ireland to get beyond the sectarian head-count?
There will have to be an acceptance by the Nationalist/Republican community that you�ll not be able to get the community support to attack crime if you have paramilitary organisations on either side that can seem politically to justify their existence. So there needs to be an acceptance that our constitutional position is going to remain the same for a period of time. Against that background, you could go to all the stakeholders and say what sort of Northern Ireland do you want to live in? What sort of Northern Ireland do you want your children to be brought up in? If it�s going to be one where there�s a good education system, where there�s jobs, where there�s good housing, where the infrastructure�s re-constructed, there�s much more chance of that happening and this vision in Northern Ireland where everybody is working together without thought to the end question of are we Irish or are we British. Can we not all be both?
Is this not the agenda the pro-Agreement Unionists were buying into?
I�m not so sure. I voted No because I thought this is absolutely ridiculous. I read the agreement and I saw things in it that I totally disagreed with. The DUP know there�s going to be a community government and they are quite prepared to share power with other democratic parties. The responsibility is largely on the Republican movement to have the confidence to stand on their political seat and to say this is our political view and we are going to articulate in every way we can, with all the force we can, using peaceful means only. Once that would be established in the Unionists� mind, I don�t see a big problem with finding a form of government that�s acceptable.
Mick is founding editor of Slugger. He has written papers on the impacts of the Internet on politics and the wider media and is a regular guest and speaking events across Ireland, the UK and Europe. Twitter: @MickFealty
Discover more from Slugger O'Toole
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

