Reconciliation means moving beyond simplified explanations to a citizen’s view of the long term…

embrace, hug, solidarity

This long term perspective from Jarlath Kearney last week in his Irish News column is a piece of the bigger picture which (I reckon at least) we all really need to hear (if “it’s not too much effort not to have another war”)… There’s too much play-acting at peace-making. Reconciliation needs our urgent, relentless attention. It’s a lifetime journey – not an election cycle. Society properly focuses on big ticket news items like Brexit and borders. Similar attention is needed …

Read more…

Most significant thing today is the EU has recognised the Protocol’s drag on NI’s East West trade…

delivery, shipping, transportation

So, there’s some actual news today. My guess is that the EU’s announcement today of the compromises it’s prepared to make. Although much of it is still unquantified, the scope of the pragmatic changes are impressively wide. Some provisions, like medicines, are technically difficult to achieve and will take much more time, but the direction of travel seems to be in the direction seems to be freeing up distribution between Britain and Northern Ireland. There has barely been any acknowledgement …

Read more…

Demographic logic for a border poll is destined sink its own long term ambitions…

“The mountain is so formed that it is always wearisome when one begins the ascent, but becomes easier the higher one climbs.” – Dante, Divine Comedy, Purgatorio On Sunday I was part of a panel discussion at the Battle of Ideas entitled The Border Question: Can the Union Survive? It was lively, to say the least. The chair, Kevin Rooney, made sure there was plenty of time for audience questions. The venue, Church House, is integral to the grounds of Westminster …

Read more…

Local political pressure prompts ministers to take action on UC (rather than just complaining).

Claire Simpson in the Irish News yesterday wrote about some last minute developments in regard to the £20 cut in universal credit: STORMONT is coming under increasing pressure to find the £55 million needed to mitigate against the cut in Universal Credit. Ministers will today discuss how to help low-income families after the £20-a-week increase to Universal Credit, brought in to support claimants during the pandemic, was officially withdrawn yesterday. The cut will see more than 130,000 people in Northern …

Read more…

In London this weekend speaking on whether the UK can survive a border poll?

crocus, flowers, purple flowers

On Sunday I’ll be part of a panel at the Battle of Ideas festival discussing the motion: The Irish Border Question: Can the Union Survive? The panel comprises myself and three others. Chair is Kevin Rooney, a native of Belfast who recently launched a new blog at Irishborderpoll.com advocating for a border poll as a way of expediting a the route to a politically unified island. Andrée Murphy is a Deputy Director of Relatives for Justice, a columnist with Belfast Media and …

Read more…

Dublin looking for partners as #SharedIsland Fund doubles and all island investment rises to €3.5billion…

shaking hands, handshake, teamwork

“The past holds us captive. Even when we succeed in giving up slights, grudges, feuds and pride, we cannot easily give up knowledge, memories and experience.” – David Amerland At the weekend, Colm Tóibín wrote scathingly of some southern politicians that “their talk of a united Ireland ‘in my lifetime’ is mystical blather; another example of politicians saying something they don’t mean”. Ouch. Yet, there are some political leaders in the ‘anglosphere’ who seem to be trying to reconnect to …

Read more…

Kindergarten exchanges in the Dáil pit ‘aimless chatter’ against ‘planned, concerted action’.

goal, target, arrow

Interesting how in the Labour leader’s speech on Wednesday dealt with heckling from a minority of conference delegates. The stand out response was one he had clearly pre-prepared: “chanting slogans or changing lives”. It had an immediate effect on the audience in the hall, and judging by the unusually positive reviews for the UK Labour leader on some beyond, acting as a philosophical razor between ‘aimless chatter’ and ‘planned, concerted action’. Heckling plays a large part in modern politics (Twitter is …

Read more…

Yesterday’s Ulster Day Declaration should signal the beginning of the end of a crisis not presage yet another drama

off road, jeep, trail

Brian (O’Neill) tells me it was Ulster Day yesterday (28th September), the anniversary of the signing the Ulster Solemn League and Covenant or the women’s Declaration, almost a foundational document for political unionism ever since. Owen Polley explains… Yesterday, Northern Ireland’s four explicitly unionist parties issued a ‘declaration’ affirming their opposition to the Northern Ireland Protocol. This statement was timed to coincide with the anniversary of ‘Ulster Day’ in 1912. 109 years ago, on the 28th of September, almost half …

Read more…

History can light the way, but it’s what we bring to the question today that really matters… 

brushes, painter, work shop

It’s hard to believe that in the wake of their boycott of the Queen’s visit to the Republic in 2011, Sinn Féin’s First Minister Martin McGuinness petitioned to meet her on a subsequent visit to Northern Ireland. As we’ve come closer to the anniversary of partition attitudes have not just hardened, but got more slapdash and careless. As Tony Horwitz writes of the remnants of the American civil war he found in the 1990s: Everywhere, it seemed, I had to …

Read more…

Gazing back 100 years will lead to a crick in the neck rather than the insights we need to grow…

highway, mountain, trees

And to finish the week, Newton Emerson throws some light on the politics of the President’s refusal to come Armagh in October as a part of the decade of centenaries… Under his Machnamh centenary programme, described as “inviting reflections on the War of Independence, the Treaty Negotiations, the Civil War and Partition”, the President has spent a year hosting academic seminars on contested commemoration, ethical remembering and, above all, on colonialism as the overriding context for the centenary. It is …

Read more…

FF rebels should know there’s no home to return to, yet the journey ahead could be transformative

It’s interesting how Fianna Fáil has almost disappeared from the national consciousness in the Republic for much of the last five or six years. And despite being in office, not much gets into print about current Taoiseach Micheál Martin. However, Theresa Reidy has written thoughtfully on what may lie ahead for a party that, historically, did not have to think about its profile, its image, trajectory and story (which was pretty much one with the story of government). Fianna Fáil’s …

Read more…

Northern Ireland started as a temporary bodge but by 2021 it has become permanent fixtures

tree, log, firewood

Whatever thinking or writing we do, however we choose to couch it and whatever our explanatory ambition, we do it from the midst of things, not from above or beyond the fray. There are different ways of articulating that relationship – more remote or more immediate – but no way out of that situatedness. – Adam Tooze On Slugger we are trying to make sense of things in a world where everything screams at you to take it more seriously than …

Read more…

Michael D Higgins’ shifting stories indicate a weakening defence of the Belfast Agreement

II’m glad I put yesterday’s blog out before President Higgins gave his ‘explanation’ about why he wasn’t coming to this joint service, because in its absence I preferred to focus on the bigger picture and why it is important to move on. When it did come out, many people, including here in the Slugger comment zone and elsewhere found  they had argued in the belief the President had been snubbed he was entitled take umbrage and refuse to come north. …

Read more…

Not the time to turn away from seeking a firm resolution over the protocol in Dublin or Belfast…

It’s hard to know what to say about the decision of the Irish President not to attend a cross community commemoration (not celebration) of the 100th anniversary in Armagh, the ecclesiastical centre of the whole island. The BBC reports that SDLP leader Colum Eastwood said people should take President Higgins “at his word when he says he can not be there”. The Irish government says it has played no part in his decision, because, well, it can’t. Ironically the DUP (currently …

Read more…

Limitations of the ‘infinite jest’ and standing up for the freedom and the right to be human… 

“Wittgenstein realised [that] no conclusion could be more horrible than solipsism.” – David Foster Wallace. Complacent solipsism is becoming the defining characteristic of the 21C. Kathy Sheridan in The Irish Times picks up the baton after columnist Niamh Walsh lammed into three female FF parliamentarians, simply for how they looked: The point-and-laugh piece included tired old tropes such as outrage/hilarity at false tans, hairstyles, outfits, shoe-shapes and to avoid the woman-bashing rap, a mention of male bellies and boring blue suits. …

Read more…

Raducanu’s extraordinary win affords us a glimpse of Britain’s fascinating demography…

Photo of Lanterns in London Chinatown during COVID-19 Pandemic.

I recently read that between 1991 and 2011 some 25% of all babies born in England and Wales were born to women who were born outside the UK. Sunder Katwala contextualises the new British US Open champion in these terms: If Emma-mania is the theme of the sporting year, does that tell us anything about identity, migration and integration in Britain today? Sport’s role in society has made it a focal point on identity for decades – about social class in …

Read more…

If Populism is a rational response to how we chose to structure our political debates, we need to slow things down…

photographs, lenses, photography

“In newspaper work you have to learn to forget every day what happened the day before. Newspaper work is valuable up to the point it begins to destroy your memory.” – Hemingway As my engineer friend Hugh puts it, for much of my time on Slugger, I’ve tried only to share what I feel is important, perhaps not obvious but nevertheless true. That’s increasingly important in a world abundant in information. If you can (and you haven’t already), I thoroughly recommend …

Read more…

Top two Fine Gael players in government find themselves in a swamp of their own making

mud, earth, red

Sometimes, only satire can be relied on to report what would otherwise be classed as the bleeding’ obvious. Mario Rosenstock’s skill in showing a good man (Paschal Donohoe) losing it (which he rarely does in real life) is put to good use here as he interrupts Leo preening over his picture chilling at a London music festival at the weekend. First we had Merrion-Gate, could this be Mighty Hoopla-Gate?! 👀 @GiftGrubMario @IanDempsey https://t.co/IC6PEhTkHC — Today FM 💛 (@TodayFM) September 6, …

Read more…

Finding Solutions and Enacting Opportunities: The Protocol

align fingers, index fingers, hands

“Only connect, and the beast and the monk, robbed of the isolation that is life to either, will die.” – EM Foster Yesterday, I took the unusual decision (for me) to sign an open letter calling for some proportion and sense to prevail within the negotiations between the EU and UK over how the Northern Irish Protocol will work post grace period. It seems to me there’s been a failure of imagination around these issues, with Mr Johnson’s UK administration …

Read more…

PSNI report: Credible attempt to anchor the policing service within the life of a Republican community. 

An interesting responses to a new report out from the PSNI, which makes several recommendations for changing how it polices south Armagh. There’s a lot of material in there, including performance comparisons with Newtonhamilton. Such as… 1,606 stop and searches were carried out in D District between April 2019 and December 2019. Within this period Crossmaglen LPT used stop and search powers on 6 occasions and Newtownhamilton LPT on 166 occasions. There’s a fair amount of emphasis on how despite …

Read more…