Will the PSNI and courts apply law impartially and arrest, charge road-blocking loyalists?

1 views

After the PSNI’s dismal performance at Belfast City Hall on Monday night, there will be a renewed focus on how that organisation responds following the latest loyalist law-breaking tonight in Ards and Carrickfergus, where roads have been blocked by loyalists. Following a road blocking protest in July 2010 by republicans, 26 people were brought to court and fined between £400 and £600 each in December 2011. It will be very interesting to see if the PSNI are willing to apply the law in an impartial, non-partisan manner in this regard, not least given that their record in facing down the sectarian bully boy antics of East Antrim’s loyalists has not been good in recent years.

  • DC

    The Alliance office has been set alight in Carrickfergus, apparently.

  • keano10

    Reports also tonight that there is going to be a large demonstration in Belfast City Centre on Saturday. Right in the middle of Christmas Shopping. The outcome is virtually inevitable.

    I’m afraid that the DUP have unleashed the hounds and can no longer control them. I just hope that someone has the courtesy to warn the tourists what’s coming their way in not-so-festive Belfast…

  • DC

    The odd dissident murder here and there hasn’t helped, neither the silly motion to remove the flag altogether therefore bringing in the media’s attention because of the sheer stupidity, Pinky and the Brain style.

    Pinky: “Gee, Brain, what do you want to do tonight?”
    The Brain: “The same thing we do every night, Pinky—try to take over the world!”

  • Mick Fealty
  • chewnicked

    ‘Unleashed the hounds?’ Cringeworthy sensationalism or what? Keano’s crass and vacuous contributions are symptomatic of the decline in the quality of debate on this site and confirms that even a fleeting visit to Slugger is a waste of time in terms of dumbing down Keano ‘style’

  • RegisterForThisSite

    I seem to recall Slugger claiming that SF would not be welcoming the Police and Fire Games next year,…. but I didn’t realise that the DUP were going to try so hard to get them started early

  • Toastedpuffin

    Did we ever find out whether Sinn Fein applied for permission to hold this protest, and whether they consulted with local residents, I can’t remember?

    http://www.u.tv/news/Protest-at-IRA-charges-against-SF-member/a9b9aa7d-284c-4c7f-b033-62a17042bcb4

  • http://WindowsIDHotmail danielsmoran

    Keano, the genie can’t so easdily be put back in the bottle and I think we’re now entering a period of uncharted territory here, becuse there’s never in the history of NI where the unionists alleged commitment to democracy has really been tested. It will from now on and the stability of the statelet is no longer to be taken for granted. Stormont will not survive a failure of Robbo to stay in FM post and that’s where the DUP will decide it’s no longer useful to carry it on. As if dealing with the decasde of annioversaires wasn’t challening enough, it’s now in danger of being overtaken.

  • http://ardoynerepublican.blogspot.com/ Ardoyne Republican

    There;s no chance of charges being brought against Loyalist/Uniotnists for blocking roads my friends as they block the Upper Crumlin/Woodvale Roads and Twaddle Avenue every time an unwelcome secterian march goes through Greater Ardoyne.

    They have never been warned nor cautioned by the renamed RUC, nor have they been arrested or charged either?

    While over 30 GARC Activists & Supporters were arrested, charged and convicted for a Peaceful Protest in opposition to an Orange Order march in July 2010.

  • DC
  • Comrade Stalin

    Loyalists are busy on facebook at the moment and are organizing “protests” (such as the one this evening in Carrickfergus) outside other Alliance offices. David Ford’s office in Antrim is on the list.

    The leadership of unionism is responsible for this. I appreciate that unionists have very strong feelings about the removal of the flag. But the use of disinformation, leafleting campaigns and inflammatory rhetoric is what has led to this protest and the refusal of unionism to distance itself effectively from these tactics is what is going to lead to it continuing.

    David Ford should now demand that the First Minister unequivocally condemns these attacks and call upon anyone with knowledge of them to report to the police; and that the Executive develop and adopt a new policy aimed at shutting down all of the residual paramilitary elements in our society. If this cannot be agreed David Ford’s position in the Executive is untenable. How can you participate in a government when the leadership of that government stand back and issue mealy-mouthed pleasantries about paramilitary violence and intimidation ?

  • http://WindowsIDHotmail danielsmoran

    Crhis, since Baggot took over it’s been all downhill for the new synthetic RUC clone and it’s going to take a very long Policing Board meeting to sort this out.Baggott should be sacked for Monday night’s dereliction of duty alone.

  • keano10

    There does seem to a huge orchestration of this ongoing protest being conducted via Social Media, and, in particular, Facebook. If 1,600 people can turn-up in Carrickfergus on a bitterly cold night, one wonders how many people might descend on Belfast City Hall this coming Saturday afternoon.

    It was the DUP who initially distributed 40,000 leaflets to initiate this protest action but it’s quite clear that the PUP/UVF intend to take this protest in an entirely different direction…

  • iluvni

    Ford’s position in the Executive is a sham to begin with. Time the whole rotten lot was shut down and the politicians, their advisors and the whole damned lot of them, and their hangers on in the community relations industry, bathed in public money, were thrown out the door.
    Then they can all start again developing a set up which demands honesty and integrity.

  • Toastedpuffin

    “How can you participate in a government when the leadership of that government stand back and issue mealy-mouthed pleasantries about paramilitary violence and intimidation ?”

    I suppose the same way you do when the leadership of that government takes part in re-enactments of paramilitary death squad activities in south Armagh and Derry…

  • Mick Fealty

    Something has definitely got out of the bottle, but I doubt its offering wishes… Is it those poisonous foundations wavering?

  • Submariner

    “I suppose the same way you do when the leadership of that government takes part in re-enactments of paramilitary death squad activities in south Armagh and Derry…”

    Enough about the covenant parade what is your view on the ongoing violence in Carrick.

  • Comrade Stalin

    ToastedPuffin,

    People are being put out of their houses, intimidation of Alliancers is rife, and the party’s constituency offices are being targetted. The best you can do is come up with whataboutery. I completely oppose such re-enactments, but idiots playing toy soldiers and trying to keep alive the flagging memory of their defeated organization is insignificant relative to what is happening here.

    Martin McGuinness called the dissident murderers “traitors”. I am entitled to hear Peter Robinson describe those engaged in this violent campaign in the same terms.

  • Drumlins Rock

    From Mark Devonports Twitter.

    “East Antrim MP Sammy Wilson condemns “carnage” in Carrickfergus – says those involved do disservice to flag they claim to defend ”

    “UUP leader Mike Nesbitt says violence wrong legally and morally – unionism needs brains not brawn “

  • Toastedpuffin

    CS:

    I’m just suggesting that if your concern is for the integrity of our assembly, you’re several years too late. I’d have thought that such a concern might have found voice before.

    So Martin McGuinness has condemned Republicans who oppose his strategy. Great. How’s his memory coming along concerning injustices perpetrated by the paramilitary organisation he headed then, eh? Have the paramilitary re-enactments he’s been attending triggered any happy memories?

    Look, I can’t stand Robinson, and yes he is dragging his heels over condemning loyalist violence (morality takes one for the votes), but to start at this stage to question if our political leadership has any integrity when you look at the atrocities elements of it have been personally responsible for and continue to glorify, I’ve got to wonder if you’ve just been beamed down from outer space.

  • babyface finlayson

    What could the protests hope to achieve. Does anyone think the council will vote again and come up with a different decision?
    Clearly the moronic rabble don’t care, but do the organisers of these protests offer any fig leaf of an objective?

  • Politico68

    Both Belfast and Derry are both pretty much Nationalist cities now but that does not mean that Unionism should be just swept aside, its time for leaders on both side to come up with a plan that involves giving both tradition equal respect. Why not fly the Union flag every day of the year from City hall with the Tricolour flying beside it?

  • GavBelfast

    Said it once and I’ll say it again: this is one political slum.

    As for the PSNI response: well, at least we’ve seen baton rounds and some actual arrests on the night (for a change).

    More please: whoever the aggressors are.

  • Submariner

    Totally agree Gav, the PSNI have been found wanting on occasion, hopefully they will be making lots more arrests in the weeks to come. The courts also need to deal with these scum and that means no bail and long prison sentences if convicted.

  • Politico68

    Sadly we are most likely going to see a lot more violence as the reality of Nationalist encroachment continues. Belfast is lost to Unionism as so many other towns and cities in the North are. The centre of the once great Unionist Monolith has been hollowed out and very soon there will be nothing more than an egg shell left. Political Unionisms sneaking regard for Loyalist violence only confirms what Nationalists always knew to be true. Unionism can only accept democracy on the basis of a very narrow definition of the word as it pertains to their own criteria. It cannot accept defeat, A bit like a grieving mother standing at a gate waiting for her dead son to return, he never does and she withers away with grief and despair her only companions. She destroys her own chances of happiness just as Unionism destroys its own chances of survival. Whatever the IRA or the British or Irish or Rome or Europe or America ever did to damage Unionism pales in comparison to what Unionism has done to itself time and time again. Its sad, very sad.

  • qwerty12345

    “UUP leader Mike Nesbitt says violence wrong legally and morally – unionism needs brains not brawn “

    Really trying not to troll….

  • Comrade Stalin

    ToastedPuffin,

    Look we are not going to agree on a lot of stuff, but you are arguing that the institutions have no credibility because they wallpaper over the deeds of various people in the past. I don’t see what the alternative is. My own attitude is to draw a line under things that happened more than a few years ago and try to move forward, looking to the future. I think the republicans, broadly speaking, are doing that and most of the time unionists are doing it too. I know this is a lot easier for me than it is for other people who were directly affected in horrible ways by the troubles, but it creates a basis upon which to move forward.

    When the dissidents began shooting police officers and soldiers again Martin McGuinness called them “traitors”. McGuinness had no choice. The political process would not have been able to stand had he failed to condemn the murders in the strongest terms. Burning out an office or intimidating elected reps is not in the same ballpark as murdering police and soldiers, but I don’t see why this word is not appropriate. I can only speculate about why unionists are being so guarded in their condemnation and it must be because they feel they need hardline loyalists onside. I think this is in complete contrast with the Shinners who basically cut the dissidents adrift. I don’t see why the unionists are so hesitant to cut the irreformable UDA and UVF adrift.

  • Comrade Stalin

    I noticed earlier today a comment “what is in all this for the DUP” but I did not get a chance to answer.

    I think the DUP were hoping to rally unionist opinion around the notion that Belfast should have a permanent union jack over it, weakening Alliance in East Belfast in particular. I think the DUP knew that there would be a violent reaction to their highlighting of the cause. I do not think they sought specifically to encourage that reaction but I think they were aware that it would happen and did not care. They calculated that they would win more support from people angered by the flag decision than they would lose support from people who are fed up with the stupid politicking over tribalism and symbols.

    I think, however, they have not thought it through. If you are a unionist and you are angered by what the DUP are portraying as a joint nationalist initiative to destroy unionist heritage, the first question you are going to ask is “why are you still in government with Sinn Féin in Stormont?”. I saw a lot of unionists demanding this from their DUP reps on Facebook.

    It seems like a grave strategic miscalculation to act on a local level to undermine the case for powersharing at a regional level. The DUP policy here is simply to point out that unionists would be better off voting for the TUV who are committed to excluding Sinn Féin from power.

  • Comrade Stalin

    Christine and Michael Bower, two young Alliance councillors, have had their house attacked. Their small baby, Grace, is a little over 1 year old.

  • Kevsterino

    I am having a harder time believing this bs is over how often to fly a flag at city hall.

    A one-year-old in the house and they can’t find it in their hearts to spare it.

    Unbelievable.

  • http://ardoynerepublican.blogspot.com/ Ardoyne Republican

    Unlike the Ardoyne residents & supporters who were involved in a fully peaceful demonstration in 2010. The thugs of Monday night and tonight have used violence. So, it will be very interesting to see if the unreformed RUC actually arrest and charge all those involved in tonights actions?

    Especially after they were encouraged to take to the streets by the DUP & UUP and who are NOW condemning those involved. Predictably, those who took to the streets this week, will be abandoned by ‘Mainstream Unionists’ as they have been for over a century, used & abused!

  • Mick Fealty

    CS,

    “the institutions have no credibility because they wallpaper over the deeds of various people in the past…”

    I really don’t think that’s the problem. This is the problem:

    “In reality, it’s a no-party system, designed to operate in the sectarian bunkers, giving voters no great alternative (just a little Alliance somewhere in the middle). If the flaw that’s blighting devolution in Scotland is that things were subtly rigged to keep the Nats out of the action, so the flaw here is that Stormont is rigged for “normal” stagnation, disillusion and recurrent crisis at the whim of any supposed partner. The centre cannot hold because there isn’t a proper centre to begin with. What of the next election and the one after that? Chant “more of the same” until supplies of sameness run out? What if Ulster’s general election vote holds the British balance? Chant “chaos is come again”.

    “The awkward truth, demonstrated yet again as the legacy-makers depart, is that mainland UK wants shot of this problem. Hold on to Scotland at all costs, but let Northern Ireland go its own sweet way as the troops head home. Been there, done that, had enough. But the coalition we leave behind isn’t a way forward, more a full stop: an agreement to play politics for a while rather than play demagogues or gunmen. And the underlying craving for justice in a fresh, non-sectarian land? Ah! It’s party-party time. Pour one for Nuala.”

    We’ve all bought the idea that if you pay people to behave like politicians they will behave like politicians and eventually become like politicians. Well, for the most part it’s bought us peace. Except on nights like this when those who don’t speak tribal get it in the neck.

  • simtrib

    Sadly we are most likely going to see a lot more violence as the reality of Nationalist encroachment continues. Belfast is lost to Unionism as so many other towns and cities in the North are. The centre of the once great Unionist Monolith has been hollowed out and very soon there will be nothing more than an egg shell left. Political Unionisms sneaking regard for Loyalist violence only confirms what Nationalists always knew to be true. Unionism can only accept democracy on the basis of a very narrow definition of the word as it pertains to their own criteria. It cannot accept defeat, A bit like a grieving mother standing at a gate waiting for her dead son to return, he never does and she withers away with grief and despair her only companions.

    Unfortunately for your simplicity the idea that Belfast is a majority nationalist city in 2012 is no more plausible than that Derry was a majority unionist city in 1972.

    I don’t say this as some point scoring troll post. That is actual reality on the ground. I really do think that you need to have some cognisance of that actual fact, and to find some way to deal with it, because it is a fact that will come up again and again in the future. Without a doubt.

    Like Glasgow Belfast was a highly dense industrial city that has now suburbinised after “slum clearance”. This fact isn’t going to go away. De jure legitimacy is no replacement for de facto legitimacy. The fact is that Belfast City Council can be gerrymandered to be majority nationalist, majority unionist, or Alliance with the balance of power, and none of those options are really natural, they all occur at the stroke of someone’s pen.

    I’m not offering a solution. I don’t have one. I just don’t wan’t to be the “someone” in question. The question of “democracy” though is nowhere near as simple as you present it.

  • Mick Fealty

    For balance, Gonzo’s account of the Republican rioting in Ardoyne of 2009 is well worth revisiting: http://goo.gl/V8D4G

    It doesn’t show the handgun being fired at the PSNI, or the plastic bullets being fired at the rioters. But we do know it was not triggered by the actual presence of marchers.

  • http://ardoynerepublican.blogspot.com/ Ardoyne Republican

    From BBC News Website Tonight;

    Press photographers must hand over to police all material relating to a riot in Belfast, a judge has ruled;
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-20616107

    Political & Partial Police Still focused on Ardoyne, while forgetting Unionist Rioting in August and this week!

  • ayeYerMa

    The demands from Ford to try and blame politicians DUP and UUP politicans is rather disingenuous given Unionist parties have been quick to make numerous condemnations of violence over the last few days. (Sounds very reminiscent of the SDLP)

    It seems to be more of the same usual preachy blame everyone else game that Alliance like to play, but now one exposed given that Alliance have actually made a decision.

    The idea that you can in response to an initiative from Republicans (often violent Republicans, and in this case with several only on Belfast City Council after terrorist convictions) make decisions over the head of Ulster Unionists (people who have fought for their own right to self-determination while also conceding to and then respecting Irish Republican self-determination in the south) and then preach to them that you are making a “compromise” is a recurring theme of the Appeasement Process, from Sunningdale, to the Anglo-Irish Agreement, to the Belfast Agreement (with the DUP not involved and it dubious whether it received majority Unionist support at all with most UUP MPs also against). The only fragile strand that kept Unionists on board in 1998, despite the fact that almost every other political concession has been towards Nationalism, was the single core issue that the sovereignty of Northern Ireland would be acknowledged and respected.

    I just don’t think these preachy Alliance types really understand how incredibly provocative their decision-making has been here. The idea of removing the acknowledgement of such sovereignty that has existed for over a century in the focal point of the capital (one with sprawling boundaries more than just the current council area) goes right to this core issue which kept marginal Unionist support for the flawed idea that you can simply whitewash decades of terror. It is in effect a breach of the ethos of the Good Friday Agreement. Breaches which could easily unravel this farcical concept of “drawing a line”.

  • iluvni

    Of all the politicians in Stormont, I must say Ford is at the top of the contempt-o-meter too.

  • simtrib

    The idea of removing the acknowledgement of such sovereignty that has existed for over a century in the focal point of the capital (one with sprawling boundaries more than just the current council area)

    The conurbation has 580,000 people and the “city” has 270,000 people. I challenge anyone to name a UK city with a greater conurbation to “city” ratio.

  • http://gravatar.com/joeharron Mister_Joe

    Would it be proper for the Justice Minister to enquire of the Chief Constable whether a person of interest in a criminal investigation who became unwell has now recovered sufficiently to be interviewed? Or should he just wait a couple of years to see what happens?

  • boondock

    Simtrib
    You seem to be implying that nationalists have some how rigged the boundaries of Belfast City Council. Thess boundaries have been in place for 40 years and back in the good old days unionists had 3 times as many councillors as nationalists. Now that changing demographics have changed the outlook of the city suddenly unionism is calling for new boundaries to be drawn (god this sounds awfully familiar). If they were smart they would have dealt with this decades ago and it wouldnt then have been quite such an obvious snub to democracy.

    ”The conurbation has 580,000 people and the “city” has 270,000 people. I challenge anyone to name a UK city with a greater conurbation to “city” ratio.”

    Er not very difficult first city I thought of where I lived for many years Manchester has a population of 503000 where as the urban area or ‘greater” manchester is quoted between 2.2 and 2.7 million so challenge over and all too easy

  • http://WindowsIDHotmail danielsmoran

    Comrade/Kevsterino. They’ve learned nothing from \Drumcree ’98. This is proof they would rather get back to the old days even if it means death and destruction. Nesbitt is indulging in sound bites. Clearly there’s no leadership in unionism other than cynical use of loyalist muscle. I suppose it worked in 1974 and 98 in Drumcree but the loyalists have learned nothing from being used then and afterwards disowned as they were then by Paisley..

  • http://WindowsIDHotmail danielsmoran

    illuvni. Ford knows better than anyone he’s not up there on merit but was in reality the last resort as justice minister after neither side would accept anyone from the opposite side. He’s out of his depth totally. The BBC and UTV are totally useless at interviewing unionist politicians mainly because their symphathies lie with unionism.

  • Haifish

    There is widespread contempt of the Alliance Party amongst many in both main Unionist parties going back to Alliance being at the forefront of the campaign to bring Unionist councillors to court for non payment of rates in the anti Anglo Irish Agreement era of 1985-87.
    Add in the DUP desire to oust Long in East Belfast, and the Loyalist “sans cullottes” outrage over the symbolic lowering of the Union Flag plus the ongoing chipping away at Parades and the perfect storm brews.
    One recalls Gerry Adams persistently warning against “demonising” Republicans; well Loyalists have been well and truly demonised by the chattering classes, and it appears some have decided it is payback time.
    I also noticed on TV coverage of the City Hall protest, a large Ulster/Independence/Union flag being carried by several “faces” from the Lower Shankill UDA, so it seems so sort of alliance of Loyalists is coalescing here.
    The touts have been outed, so I dare say Intelligence figures are concerned at the control or lack of it they have over the emerging situation.
    If it seems bad now at the least contentious time of the year, watch and weep when the Parades Commission heap further restrictions/conditions on the parades along main arterial shared space routes like Lower Newtownards Road/Crumlin Road and Upper Donegall Street/Clifton Street.

  • boondock

    Simtrib just for ”fullness” I quickly googled a few other cities. Now there does seem to be a number of different figures for cities as there is an urban area stat and a metropolitan area stat with Belfasts own urban area rising to 650000
    London and Sheffield have smaller conurbation to city ratios than Belfast, Leeds, Edinburgh, Bristol and Cardiff have similar ie 2-1 ratio but Birmingham, Newcastle, Glasgow and Liverpool again have much higher ratios. I couldnt be bothered continuing with cities like Bradford and Sunderland but you get the idea seems like Belfast isnt such a special case!
    By the way the Belfast figure of 580000 is including Bangor, Lisburn, Carrick etc so defo outside city limits in my opinion

  • http://www.ur2die4.com/ amanfromMars

    Judge David McFarland, the Recorder for Belfast, said he had to balance the public interest of identifying and prosecuting rioters against the potential risk to journalists if seen to be assisting in the police investigation.

    He stated: “There is no evidence to support the proposition that journalists may become the targets of attack should they be perceived to be evidence gathering for the police.”” …. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-20616107

    No evidence maybe, but as the attacks on Alliance Party offices and party representative homes in the wake of an admittedly democratic/politically correct vote on flag flying clearly shows, is it more likely to be the case than not.

    Quite what Judge David McFarland was thinking, or not thinking as many may be here thinking, whenever he gave that [odd and misleading] statement, is a mystery.

  • http://www.ur2die4.com/ amanfromMars

    Would it be proper for the Justice Minister to enquire of the Chief Constable whether a person of interest in a criminal investigation who became unwell has now recovered sufficiently to be interviewed? Or should he just wait a couple of years to see what happens?….. Mister_Joe 6 December 2012 at 5:17 am

    Howdy doody, Mister_Joe,

    Who is that you are referring to? Don’t be shy, now, for we are all surely interested in justice being seen to be done in the face of it being widely perceived as being easily perverted for both private and politically incorrect gain.

  • http://www.aurient.co.uk Stephen Barnes

    According to PSNI’s own press releases, three people have already been arrested from tonight’s disturbance in Glengormley.

    From memory, that’s “Infinity percent” (it’s a maths term, work it out for yourself) greater than the number of arrests from the same period from SOME nationalist disputes.

    On the other hand, it’s only a FRACTION of the number of arrests from a particular nationalist dispute.

    Depending on your viewpoint, you can argue, from these simple statistics, that the PSNI/RUC are either fenian scum, intent on destroying the loyalist community, or they’re black bastards, with a goal of just imposing British Imperialism on the Irish Republicans.

    Statistics (facts for the mathematically challenged) are wonderful things, allowing you derive any conclusion you desire (sorry, translation…. “say what you want, like”)

    Some incidents wield 3,4, or 5 immediate arrests. Some result in no IMMEDIATE arrests, but 30 subsequent arrests. The problem is that one side only remembers the immediate arrests, and forget the subsequent arrests. The other side only remembers the subsequent arrests and forgets the immediate arrests.

    Selective memories cause issues from both sides of our single community.

    In reality, there is no difference. Except your own bias.

  • Comrade Stalin

    Haifish

    well Loyalists have been well and truly demonised by the chattering classes, and it appears some have decided it is payback time.

    In the scheme of things, it’s not much of a payback.

    Meanwhile, I’m very proud of the Alliance councillors who show the same steel in the face of this kind of intimidation that Alliancers did back in 1985 when they took the unionist politicians to court. Addie Morrow (RIP) told a few years ago of how a young and relatively newly minted MP named Peter Robinson screamed at him “I’ll take your farm off you”).

    Daniel:

    I suppose it worked in 1974 and 98 in Drumcree but the loyalists have learned nothing from being used then and afterwards disowned as they were then by Paisley..

    It depends what you mean by “worked”. 1974 was really the only success they had in terms of forcing the Assembly down but it serves as a reminder of how loyalists are merely pawns in the wider agenda, which (deja vu) was about the leader of the DUP trying to knock the Ulster Unionists off their perch, and damn the consequences.

    1985 was another big push. They huffed and puffed, screamed and yelled, protested .. but nothing happened.

    As for Drumcree 98 .. Orangemen haven’t marched down that road ever since. And it seems unlikely they ever will. Had a slightly more tactful approach been taken it’s possible there would be a march there now.

  • http://gravatar.com/joeharron Mister_Joe

    Answer to the question posed in the header: Not really. There will be a few minor arrests, the people being released without charge. The claim that the PSNI are operationally independent is, at best, a sick joke.