Other Election News

Despite the apparent reluctance of RTÉ and the Irish Times to say so, there is only one way to describe these comments by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in Rome.. and that is.. a campaign speech.

The RTE report has been somewhat diluted from the initial report I noted, so here are the relevant details from the Irish Times breaking news report –

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger has told fellow prelates today they must choose a new pontiff who would defend traditional teachings and reject attempts to modernise doctrine.

Cardinal Ratzinger, a 78-year-old German who is seen as a front-runner to become pope,

issued his stern warning to other cardinals at a Mass just hours before they were to be locked up in a conclave to find a successor to Pope John Paul.

All of the 115 cardinal electors under the age of 80 who will enter the conclave joined older cardinals, bishops, priests, nuns and the simple faithful in today’s service in St. Peter’s Basilica.

The faith of many Christians had been shaken “by so many currents, ideologies and different ways of thinking” and the Catholic Church faced an uncertain future threatened by the rise of Christian sects around the world, Cardinal Ratzinger, the Vatican’s doctrinal chief, said in a homily.

“Having a clear faith according to the creed of the Church is often labelled as fundamentalism,” he said, adding that the Church had to reject “a dictatorship of relativism” that denied the existence of absolute truths.

“An adult faith is not one that follows tides of trends and the latest novelties. To be adult and mature the faith must be deeply rooted in friendship with Christ,” he said.

However, as the Irsh Times notes –

Since John Paul’s death on April 2th, media and bookmakers have tipped Cardinal Ratzinger as the early favourite to succeed him.

But most Vatican experts doubt that the German, whose conservative dogma has polarised the Catholic world, will be able to secure the two-thirds majority needed to become pope, leaving the field wide open.

In papal conclaves, it is considered a disadvantage to break from the pack too early.

  • Jimmy Sands

    According to one report he is a former member of the Hitler Youth. Clearly the candidate for those who believe the Church has had too much good press in recent years.

  • sean west

    I think Prince Harry would have loved to have been in the Hitler youth.

  • Ringo

    SW –
    Funny, I didn’t see any references to Prince Harry or anyone else in the piece. Where did you get such insight ? Or were you just being a hopeless reactionary, responding to an allegation of against a member of the Catholic Hierarchy by throwing out an allegation against a member of the British royalty?

    Jimmy –
    I remember hearing that story a few years ago when he was first being touted as a potential successor.

  • Occasional Commenter

    Ringo, Prince Harry wore a Nazi outfit. Here’s the picture
    But it’s still off-topic.

    Does Godwin’s Law apply to cardinals in the conclave?

  • Ringo

    OC –

    I’m aware of that. But what relevance does it have to this thread – other than the obvious undertones? Its not like we’re 400 posts into it and off on a bit of a tangent.

    Don’t think Godwin applies here – more a bad dose of whataboutery 😉

  • peteb

    As I understand it, membership of that particular organisation was compulsory at the time… which would suggest that it’s an irrelevant point to raise in regard to Cardinal Ratzinger.

  • peteb

    Not to mention playing the man and not the ball.

  • Jimmy_Sands

    Pete, I suspect you’re right about relevance, but I didn’t raise the point as mere abuse. The appointment of someone with that baggage would be a PR nightmare.

  • peteb

    According to an article linked at Irish Eagle, there’s not, in fact, that much baggage there.

  • Jimmy_Sands

    It’s a good article, and the Times piec linked to it is very silly. Unfair as it is, inevitably he will be beaten over the head with this.